{"title":"The specificity of the interpretation of Rodelinda’s pa rt from G. Handel’s opera “Rodelinda”: interpretological approa","authors":"Xin Yuan","doi":"10.34064/khnum2-24.05","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Statement of the problem. Among the questions that arise, let us single out those that will form the basis of the proposed article devoted to women’s parts in the opera “Rodelinda”: HIP traditions and staging strategies; vocal roles and their possible modifications / transformations under the conditions of specific directing and performing solutions. Analysis of recent scientific publications shows that ‘Handeliana’ is currently very voluminous. Thus, the works of W. Dean (1969), J. Knapp (2009) and C. Hogwood (2007), which have been republished several times, are considered thoroughly; L. Silke (2014) summarized the experience of predecessors and presented new dimensions of scientific understanding of Handel’s legacy. Fundamental are the studies by L. Kirillina (2019). The problem of performing vocal music of the Baroque era has been actively discussed in the works of I. Fedoseev (1996), N. Harnoncourt (2002), G. Kaganov (2013), M. Burden (2009), A. Jones (2006), О. Kruglova (2007), G. Konson & I. Konson (2020). The purpose of the article is to single out the main parameters of the baroque performance of women’s parts in G.F. Handel’s opera “Rodelinda” taking into account the performing traditions and modern trends. The research methodology is focused on the concept of “authentic performing strategy” (Yu. Nikolaievska, 2020), positions of comparative interpretology (Ch. Zhiwei, 2012) and interpretative approach, aimed at studying the specifics of the performance versions. The scientific novelty of the article lies in the application of an interpretive approach to the study of G. F. Handel’s operas. Results. In the 1938 recording (conducted by G. Leonhard), Rodelinda was performed by the famous Cecile Reich, in 1959, 1973 – by Joan Sutherland (in London and Netherlands productions). Closer to the authentic versions is the one performed by Sophie Danneman (1996); there is also a famous recording of 2005 with Rene Fleming (Metropolitan Opera), who was brilliant as an actress (which is required by the plot), but she admired and “played” her voice a little, which does not quite correspond to the principles of authenticity. One of the stars of the Glyndebourne Festival (1998) was the performer of Rodelinda’s part – Anna Caterina Antonacci, who performed her part with the necessary psychological and vocal accents, but, perhaps, somewhat dry and removed, which is why the listener is also removed from the heroine’s tragedy. In 2011 N. Harnoncourt recorded “Rodelinda” (in the title role – Danielle de Niese, who owns the entire arsenal of means inherent in baroque performance). Lauren Woods (recording of the 2016) is one of the most famous performers of the baroque repertoire. Critics have noted her perfect articulation, acting ability and “impressive vocals”. Simone Kermes, who critics call “the mad queen of the Baroque”, is distinguished by bright and temperamental performance, especially incomparable in the interpretation of baroque operas. Conclusions. From the interpretive point of view, mastering the expressive system of Baroque vocal performance traditions, in particular the art of vocal improvisation and ornamentation, consistent with the artistic context and directorial decision, can broadcast for the modern listener the affects and meanings of Handel’s music. The established features of baroque style are marked (affect, which is usually concentrated in such positions as tempo-rhythm, tonality, text, syntax of the melody) and performance (timbre, dynamics, intonation of the melodic line, ornamentation). Rodelinda’s part has been shown to require the ability to switch from one affect to another fairly quickly. In the analyzed interpretations, modern singers (D. de Nies, J. Sutherland, S. Kermez, L. Woods, A. K. Antonacci) practically do not allow themselves to be free, but seek to follow the principles of authentic performance, which is manifested in dynamic, agogic elements, various timbre colors arias (aria of revenge, duet-consent, aria of lamento), the ability to improvise.","PeriodicalId":302721,"journal":{"name":"Aspects of Historical Musicology","volume":"1 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2021-10-13","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Aspects of Historical Musicology","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.34064/khnum2-24.05","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Statement of the problem. Among the questions that arise, let us single out those that will form the basis of the proposed article devoted to women’s parts in the opera “Rodelinda”: HIP traditions and staging strategies; vocal roles and their possible modifications / transformations under the conditions of specific directing and performing solutions. Analysis of recent scientific publications shows that ‘Handeliana’ is currently very voluminous. Thus, the works of W. Dean (1969), J. Knapp (2009) and C. Hogwood (2007), which have been republished several times, are considered thoroughly; L. Silke (2014) summarized the experience of predecessors and presented new dimensions of scientific understanding of Handel’s legacy. Fundamental are the studies by L. Kirillina (2019). The problem of performing vocal music of the Baroque era has been actively discussed in the works of I. Fedoseev (1996), N. Harnoncourt (2002), G. Kaganov (2013), M. Burden (2009), A. Jones (2006), О. Kruglova (2007), G. Konson & I. Konson (2020). The purpose of the article is to single out the main parameters of the baroque performance of women’s parts in G.F. Handel’s opera “Rodelinda” taking into account the performing traditions and modern trends. The research methodology is focused on the concept of “authentic performing strategy” (Yu. Nikolaievska, 2020), positions of comparative interpretology (Ch. Zhiwei, 2012) and interpretative approach, aimed at studying the specifics of the performance versions. The scientific novelty of the article lies in the application of an interpretive approach to the study of G. F. Handel’s operas. Results. In the 1938 recording (conducted by G. Leonhard), Rodelinda was performed by the famous Cecile Reich, in 1959, 1973 – by Joan Sutherland (in London and Netherlands productions). Closer to the authentic versions is the one performed by Sophie Danneman (1996); there is also a famous recording of 2005 with Rene Fleming (Metropolitan Opera), who was brilliant as an actress (which is required by the plot), but she admired and “played” her voice a little, which does not quite correspond to the principles of authenticity. One of the stars of the Glyndebourne Festival (1998) was the performer of Rodelinda’s part – Anna Caterina Antonacci, who performed her part with the necessary psychological and vocal accents, but, perhaps, somewhat dry and removed, which is why the listener is also removed from the heroine’s tragedy. In 2011 N. Harnoncourt recorded “Rodelinda” (in the title role – Danielle de Niese, who owns the entire arsenal of means inherent in baroque performance). Lauren Woods (recording of the 2016) is one of the most famous performers of the baroque repertoire. Critics have noted her perfect articulation, acting ability and “impressive vocals”. Simone Kermes, who critics call “the mad queen of the Baroque”, is distinguished by bright and temperamental performance, especially incomparable in the interpretation of baroque operas. Conclusions. From the interpretive point of view, mastering the expressive system of Baroque vocal performance traditions, in particular the art of vocal improvisation and ornamentation, consistent with the artistic context and directorial decision, can broadcast for the modern listener the affects and meanings of Handel’s music. The established features of baroque style are marked (affect, which is usually concentrated in such positions as tempo-rhythm, tonality, text, syntax of the melody) and performance (timbre, dynamics, intonation of the melodic line, ornamentation). Rodelinda’s part has been shown to require the ability to switch from one affect to another fairly quickly. In the analyzed interpretations, modern singers (D. de Nies, J. Sutherland, S. Kermez, L. Woods, A. K. Antonacci) practically do not allow themselves to be free, but seek to follow the principles of authentic performance, which is manifested in dynamic, agogic elements, various timbre colors arias (aria of revenge, duet-consent, aria of lamento), the ability to improvise.
问题的陈述。在出现的问题中,让我们挑出那些将构成关于歌剧“罗德林达”中女性角色的拟议文章的基础的问题:嘻哈传统和舞台策略;声乐角色及其在特定指导和表演解决方案条件下可能的修改/转换。对最近科学出版物的分析表明,“handelana”目前非常庞大。因此,W. Dean(1969)、J. Knapp(2009)和C. Hogwood(2007)的作品被重新出版了几次,并得到了充分的考虑;L. Silke(2014)总结了前人的经验,提出了科学理解亨德尔遗产的新维度。基础是L. Kirillina(2019)的研究。在I. Fedoseev(1996)、N. Harnoncourt(2002)、G. Kaganov(2013)、M. Burden(2009)、A. Jones(2006)、О的作品中,对巴洛克时代声乐表演的问题进行了积极的讨论。Kruglova (2007), G. Konson & I. Konson(2020)。本文的目的是在考虑到表演传统和现代趋势的情况下,挑选出亨德尔歌剧“罗德林达”中女性部分巴洛克式表演的主要参数。研究方法集中于“真实执行策略”的概念(Yu。Nikolaievska, 2020)、比较解释学(Ch. Zhiwei, 2012)和解释学的立场,旨在研究表演版本的具体内容。本文的科学新颖之处在于运用阐释的方法来研究亨德尔的歌剧。结果。在1938年的录音中(由G. Leonhard指挥),Rodelinda由著名的Cecile Reich演奏,1959年,1973年-由Joan Sutherland演奏(在伦敦和荷兰制作)。索菲·丹内曼(Sophie Danneman, 1996)表演的版本更接近真实版本;还有一段著名的2005年的录音是和Rene Fleming(大都会歌剧院)合作的,她作为一个演员非常出色(这是剧情所需要的),但她对自己的声音有点欣赏和“表演”,这与真实的原则不太相符。格林德伯恩艺术节(1998)的明星之一是扮演罗德林达的演员安娜·卡特琳娜·安东纳奇,她用必要的心理和声音口音表演了她的角色,但是,也许,有点干巴巴的,这就是为什么听众也从女主角的悲剧中消失了。2011年,n·哈农考特录制了《罗德琳达》(由丹妮尔·德·尼泽饰演,她拥有巴洛克演奏的全部手段)。劳伦·伍兹(2016年录音)是巴洛克曲目中最著名的表演者之一。评论家们注意到她完美的发音、表演能力和“令人印象深刻的歌声”。西蒙娜·克梅斯被评论家称为“巴洛克的疯狂女王”,她以明快而又喜怒无常的表演而著称,尤其是在诠释巴洛克歌剧方面无与伦比。结论。从阐释的角度来看,掌握巴洛克声乐表演传统的表现体系,特别是声乐即兴和装饰艺术,与艺术语境和导演决策相一致,可以向现代听众传播亨德尔音乐的情感和意义。巴洛克风格的既定特征是显著的(影响,通常集中在节奏、调性、文本、旋律的句法等位置)和表现(音色、动态、旋律线的语调、装饰)。罗德林达扮演的角色需要有能力快速地从一种情绪转换到另一种情绪。在分析的诠释中,现代歌手(D. de Nies, J. Sutherland, S. Kermez, L. Woods, A. K. Antonacci)实际上不允许自己自由,而是寻求遵循真实表演的原则,这表现在动态的,agogic元素,各种音色的咏叹调(复仇咏叹调,二重奏,哀歌咏叹调),即兴创作的能力。