Cognitive Map of the Pedagogical Situation as a Component of the Pedagogical Situation Cognitive Model (as Exemplified by Analyzing Natural Science and Vocational Training in Colleges of the Republic of Tatarstan)
A. Kamaleeva, S. Gilmanshina, N. Nozdrina
求助PDF
{"title":"Cognitive Map of the Pedagogical Situation as a Component of the Pedagogical Situation Cognitive Model (as Exemplified by Analyzing Natural Science and Vocational Training in Colleges of the Republic of Tatarstan)","authors":"A. Kamaleeva, S. Gilmanshina, N. Nozdrina","doi":"10.2991/ESSD-19.2019.8","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Introduction-the purpose of the article is to give theoretical justification for the phased design of a cause-andeffect cognitive model; to develop and analyze a cognitive map of the pedagogical situation of this model (as exemplified by analyzing the state of natural science and vocational training in the colleges of the Republic of Tatarstan in the context of integrating new educational and professional standards). The authors tested the hypothesis of the relationship between the identified six factors (when creating a cognitive map) in the process of building a directed graph aimed at developing the student’s cognitive tools. Materials and methods: to objectively determine the problem field of the object under study, presented in the form of a cognitive map, a SWOTanalysis of the strengths and weaknesses of developing the pedagogical state was used based on a survey of college teachers from the Republic of Tatarstan. Processing the results was carried out on the basis of probabilistic assessment methods using complex factors that made it possible to identify strengths, weaknesses, drawbacks, and possible threats of the pedagogical situation under study. Results of the research: a methodology for designing a causeeffect cognitive model of a pedagogical state of natural science and vocational training was theoretically substantiated and developed based on creating and analyzing a cognitive map of this situation in the process of studying the teachers’ opinion on implementing integration processes in the system of Secondary Vocational Education at the regional level. The dynamics of the teachers’ opinion was studied using a SWOTanalysis of the results of a questionnaire which is an adapted didactic tool. It allows describing both quantitative and qualitative characteristics of the six factors identified in the process of building a cognitive map. The scientists’ works on modern Russian professional education in the context of developing cognitive pedagogy were studied and analyzed. Discussion and conclusions: the study quite adequately shows that the SWOT-analysis of the state of natural science and vocational training of the colleges in the RT which is a region with a fairly high level of economic development reveals that amid the generally positive pedagogical situation at the time being studied, a number of shortcomings have been identified: the proportion of teachers with an average age of 50 and 60 is more than 66%; shortage of educational literature; difficulties in designing curricula in accordance with the Federal State Standard-4 Secondary Vocational Education, namely in selecting and correcting educational material; in applying project technology, case-technology, playing technologies; in organizing students’ independent work. The results of the study on the cognitive modeling of the pedagogical situation may be useful to specialists in the field of education, as well as interesting to the general public. Annotation. The article gives theoretical justification and algorithm of gradual designing a cause-and-effect cognitive model. The method of constructing and analyzing pedagogical situation cognitive maps is offered (analysis of the natural science and vocational training in colleges of the Republic of Tatarstan in terms of integrating new educational and professional standards), which is part of the cognitive model developed by the authors. The results of SWOT-analysis of strengths and weaknesses of developing the pedagogical state are presented on the basis of researching college teachers’ survey data in the Republic of Tatarstan. Keywords-cognitive modeling, pedagogical situation, cognitive map, oriented graph, cognitive model In the last decade, pedagogy and psychology development has led to the emergence of a new direction – “cognitive pedagogy”, which is gradually being developed both in theory and in practice. This led to the existence of a new understanding of training processes and education in the context of forming a person’s cognitive and personal structures. We share S.F. Sergeev’s opinion who says that “cognitive pedagogy differs from classical instrumental pedagogy by paying special attention to a person’s cognitive structures and tools and ways of their development, in contrast to the behavioral orientation inherent in traditional schools, which assesses the characteristics of the individual and the productive side of human activity” [1, p.70]. 2nd International Conference on Education Science and Social Development (ESSD 2019) Copyright © 2019, the Authors. Published by Atlantis Press. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/). Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 298","PeriodicalId":339935,"journal":{"name":"Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Education Science and Social Development (ESSD 2019)","volume":"127 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2019-07-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Proceedings of the 2nd International Conference on Education Science and Social Development (ESSD 2019)","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.2991/ESSD-19.2019.8","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
引用
批量引用
Abstract
Introduction-the purpose of the article is to give theoretical justification for the phased design of a cause-andeffect cognitive model; to develop and analyze a cognitive map of the pedagogical situation of this model (as exemplified by analyzing the state of natural science and vocational training in the colleges of the Republic of Tatarstan in the context of integrating new educational and professional standards). The authors tested the hypothesis of the relationship between the identified six factors (when creating a cognitive map) in the process of building a directed graph aimed at developing the student’s cognitive tools. Materials and methods: to objectively determine the problem field of the object under study, presented in the form of a cognitive map, a SWOTanalysis of the strengths and weaknesses of developing the pedagogical state was used based on a survey of college teachers from the Republic of Tatarstan. Processing the results was carried out on the basis of probabilistic assessment methods using complex factors that made it possible to identify strengths, weaknesses, drawbacks, and possible threats of the pedagogical situation under study. Results of the research: a methodology for designing a causeeffect cognitive model of a pedagogical state of natural science and vocational training was theoretically substantiated and developed based on creating and analyzing a cognitive map of this situation in the process of studying the teachers’ opinion on implementing integration processes in the system of Secondary Vocational Education at the regional level. The dynamics of the teachers’ opinion was studied using a SWOTanalysis of the results of a questionnaire which is an adapted didactic tool. It allows describing both quantitative and qualitative characteristics of the six factors identified in the process of building a cognitive map. The scientists’ works on modern Russian professional education in the context of developing cognitive pedagogy were studied and analyzed. Discussion and conclusions: the study quite adequately shows that the SWOT-analysis of the state of natural science and vocational training of the colleges in the RT which is a region with a fairly high level of economic development reveals that amid the generally positive pedagogical situation at the time being studied, a number of shortcomings have been identified: the proportion of teachers with an average age of 50 and 60 is more than 66%; shortage of educational literature; difficulties in designing curricula in accordance with the Federal State Standard-4 Secondary Vocational Education, namely in selecting and correcting educational material; in applying project technology, case-technology, playing technologies; in organizing students’ independent work. The results of the study on the cognitive modeling of the pedagogical situation may be useful to specialists in the field of education, as well as interesting to the general public. Annotation. The article gives theoretical justification and algorithm of gradual designing a cause-and-effect cognitive model. The method of constructing and analyzing pedagogical situation cognitive maps is offered (analysis of the natural science and vocational training in colleges of the Republic of Tatarstan in terms of integrating new educational and professional standards), which is part of the cognitive model developed by the authors. The results of SWOT-analysis of strengths and weaknesses of developing the pedagogical state are presented on the basis of researching college teachers’ survey data in the Republic of Tatarstan. Keywords-cognitive modeling, pedagogical situation, cognitive map, oriented graph, cognitive model In the last decade, pedagogy and psychology development has led to the emergence of a new direction – “cognitive pedagogy”, which is gradually being developed both in theory and in practice. This led to the existence of a new understanding of training processes and education in the context of forming a person’s cognitive and personal structures. We share S.F. Sergeev’s opinion who says that “cognitive pedagogy differs from classical instrumental pedagogy by paying special attention to a person’s cognitive structures and tools and ways of their development, in contrast to the behavioral orientation inherent in traditional schools, which assesses the characteristics of the individual and the productive side of human activity” [1, p.70]. 2nd International Conference on Education Science and Social Development (ESSD 2019) Copyright © 2019, the Authors. Published by Atlantis Press. This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/). Advances in Social Science, Education and Humanities Research, volume 298
作为教学情境认知模型组成部分的教学情境认知地图(以鞑靼斯坦共和国高校自然科学与职业培训为例)
引言——本文的目的是为因果认知模型的阶段性设计提供理论依据;开发和分析这种模式的教学状况的认知地图(例如,在整合新的教育和专业标准的背景下,分析鞑靼斯坦共和国大学的自然科学和职业培训状况)。在构建旨在开发学生认知工具的有向图的过程中,作者测试了确定的六个因素之间关系的假设(在创建认知地图时)。材料和方法:为了客观地确定研究对象的问题场,以认知地图的形式呈现,基于对鞑靼斯坦共和国大学教师的调查,对发展教学状态的优势和劣势进行了swot分析。处理结果是在概率评估方法的基础上进行的,使用复杂的因素,使得有可能确定所研究的教学情况的优势,劣势,缺点和可能的威胁。研究结果:在研究区域教师对中职教育系统实施整合过程的意见的过程中,通过创建和分析这一情况的认知图,从理论上证实和发展了自然科学与职业培训教学状态因果认知模型的设计方法。教师意见的动态研究使用问卷调查结果的swot分析,这是一个适应的教学工具。它允许描述在构建认知地图的过程中确定的六个因素的定量和定性特征。在认知教育学发展的背景下,对现代俄罗斯专业教育的研究进行了研究和分析。讨论与结论:本研究充分表明,对经济发展水平较高的黑龙江地区高校自然科学与职业培训状况的swot分析表明,在研究期间总体积极的教学形势中,也发现了一些不足之处:平均年龄在50岁和60岁之间的教师比例超过66%;教育文献缺乏;按照联邦国家标准第4号中等职业教育课程设计困难,即教材的选择和修改困难;在项目技术、案例技术、游戏技术应用方面;在组织学生独立作业方面。对教学情境的认知模型的研究结果可能对教育领域的专家有用,也可能对公众感兴趣。注释。本文给出了逐步设计因果认知模型的理论依据和算法。本文提出了构建和分析教学情境认知图的方法(从整合新教育标准和职业标准的角度分析鞑靼斯坦共和国高校的自然科学和职业培训),这是作者开发的认知模型的一部分。在对鞑靼斯坦共和国高校教师调查数据进行研究的基础上,提出了发展教学状态优势与劣势的swot分析结果。近十年来,随着教育学和心理学的发展,出现了一个新的方向——“认知教育学”,并在理论和实践上逐步得到发展。这导致在形成一个人的认知和个人结构的背景下,对培训过程和教育有了新的理解。我们同意S.F.谢尔盖夫的观点,他说“认知教育学不同于经典的工具教育学,它特别关注一个人的认知结构、工具和发展方式,而传统学校固有的行为取向则相反,它评估个人的特征和人类活动的生产方面”[1,第70页]。第二届教育科学与社会发展国际会议(ESSD 2019)版权所有©2019,作者亚特兰蒂斯出版社出版。这是一篇基于CC BY-NC许可(http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/)的开放获取文章。《社会科学、教育与人文研究进展》,第298卷
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。