Stabilité biologique des réseaux de distribution d'eau potable

Abstract

The maintenance of the quality of water from the outlet of the treatment plant to the consumer tap is a major concern of water distributors. From a biological point of view, this maintenance must be characterized by a stability of biological features, namely bacterial growth from biodegradable organic matter, and protozoan bacterivory which must be not detectable. However, drinking water distribution systems are continuously exposed to a flow of biodegradable organic matter, which can represent around 20–30 % of the total dissolved organic carbon, and a flow of allochthonous microorganisms (bacteria, fungi, protozoa…), coming from the water treatment plant but also from incidents (breaks/repairs) on the distribution network itself. Apart from these microorganisms (heterotrophic bacteria in particular) can grow in this ultra-oligotrophic environment and colonize the all drinking water distribution system. The highest density of microorganisms occurs on the surface of pipewalls where they are organized in microcolonies (biofilm) that are mixed with corrosion products and inorganic precipitates. Five groups of organisms have been identified in distribution networks, in both the water phase and the biofilm: bacterial cells, protozoa, yeast, fungi and algae. The majority of these organisms are not pathogens, nevertheless potentially pathogen bacteria (Legionella…), fecal bacteria (coliforms, E. coli…), and pathogen protozoan cysts (Giardia intestinalis, Cryptosporidium parvum…) can transitorily find favorable conditions for their proliferation in the networks. Bacteria grow from the biodegradable fraction of dissolved organic matter while protozoa grow from dissolved organic matter, other protozoa but especially from bacterial prey items. The protozoan bacterivory was extensively studied in marine aquatic environments and in rivers, lakes,… but very rarely in drinking water distribution networks. Actually, proofs of the protozoan grazing on fixed and free-living bacterial cells were given by photography or film of biofilms accumulation on coupons that were previously immersed in potable water or by direct microscopic observation of bacteria in food vacuole of protozoa from potable water. A single and recent study has estimated protozoan bacterivory rate from laboratory experiences using fluorescent markers. It appears that in an experimental distribution system fed with biologically treated water (ozone/filtration through granular activated carbon), only ciliates present in the biofilm have a measurable grazing activity, estimated at 2 bacteria·ciliate⁻¹·h⁻¹ on average.

Bacterial dynamics in drinking water distribution systems is complex and related to different parameters, like the biodegradable fraction of dissolved organic carbon, the presence of a residual of disinfectant, the nature and the state of pipewalls, the relative biomass of free and fixed bacterial, and grazing impact.

The preservation of the biological stability of potable water during its storage in reservoir or its transport through the distribution systems can be achieved by (a) the use of chemical disinfectants (in particular by addition of chlorine) which is the widely used technique, or (b) the use of new techniques such as nanofiltration that can eliminate bacteria and significantly decrease the concentrations of organic matter at the inlet of the distribution network and in the potable water.

• (a)

  The use of oxidant, usually chlorine, induces a number of problems, in particular the development of oxidation by-products like trihalomethans (THM), among which some are recognized as carcinogenic products for animals. In addition, chlorine added at the outlet of treatment plant is consumed in the network and the maintenance of a residual of chlorine along an entire distribution network would need high concentrations of chlorine at the outlet of the treatment plant. This may be incompatible with standards for both residual chlorine and its by-products. Nevertheless, chlorine has a disinfectant effect on planctonic bacteria, if considering that only around 10 % of free bacterial cells are living cells, i.e. are able of respiratory oxidation. However, some studies show that bacteria fixed on granular activated carbon particles can be resistant to chlorine, as well as bacteria in aggregates. Thus, the addition of chlorine in potable water does not inhibit the formation of a biofilm at the surface of pipewalls. In the same way, protozoa transported by potable water can resist to chlorine.

• (b)

  The above disadvantages permitted the development of membrane filtration techniques like the nanofiltration, which is at the junction between reverse osmosis and ultrafiltration, and which seems to be an interesting alternative to conventional treatments because it presents the advantage to (i) decrease very strongly the concentrations of dissolved organic carbon (on average 90 % for DOC (Dissolved Organic Carbon) and 99 % for BDOC (Biodegradable Dissolved Organic Carbon)), (ii) to remove a very high proportion of almost the entire microorganisms (99 %), precursors of chlorination by-products, and micropollutans, (iii) to decrease the musty flavor of water (2-fold) and (iv) to produce a water that needs low concentration of chlorine.