On the Evolution of Inheritance and Delegation Mechanisms and Their Impact on Code Quality

Abstract

Source code reuse is considered one of the holy grails of modern software development. Indeed, it has been widely demonstrated that this activity decreases software development and maintenance costs while increasing its overall trustwor-thiness. The Object-Oriented (OO) paradigm provides different internal mechanisms to favor code reuse, i.e., specification inheritance, implementation inheritance, and delegation. While previous studies investigated how inheritance relations impact source code quality, there is still a lack of understanding of their evolutionary aspects and, more particular, of how these mechanisms may impact source code quality over time. To bridge this gap of knowledge, this paper proposes an empirical investigation into the evolution of specification inheritance, implementation inheritance, and delegation and their impact on the variability of source code quality attributes. First, we assess how the implementation of those mechanisms varies over 15 releases of three software systems. Second, we devise a statistical approach with the aim of understanding how inheritance and delegation let source code quality—as indicated by the severity of code smells—vary in either positive or negative manner. The key results of the study indicate that inheritance and delegation evolve over time, but not in a statistically significant manner. At the same time, their evolution often leads code smell severity to be reduced, hence possibly contributing to improve code maintainability.