{"title":"How Young People are Healing the World: An Activist Reflects on the Tikkun Youth Project","authors":"Daniel Mclaughlin","doi":"10.22329/digital-press.156.252","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Young people everywhere face prejudice and discrimination. They are targeted for the same reasons older people are – because of their race, ethnicity, religion, gender, disability, or social status. They may live in societies where they face violence and deep personal strife. In addition to all of this, youth face the additional burden of discrimination on the grounds of their age. Most societies do not see young people as full citizens worthy of having a voice. Despite these barriers, the young people who participated in the Tikkun Youth Project, from five very disparate sites and demographics, demonstrated remarkable resilience, creativity, and willingness to engage with their communities. As an activist, I examined the civic engagement and rights-awareness of the young activist-researchers who appear in the international media, as well as those participating in the Tikkun Youth Project. I conclude, with some optimism, that young people are not waiting to become leaders: they are taking the reins and are making a positive difference – today. 67 | How Young People are Healing the World A young man named Aphiwe, who was from the community called Khayelitsha, an informal township in the South African city of Cape Town, told me a story. He was out for an evening with his friends. They were drinking beer (perhaps underage) in a hot and crowded venue when he decided to step outside for a breath of air, bringing his drink with him. As he was standing in front of the building, he was approached by several police officers. They told him it was illegal for him to be outside with his drink. He asked them why. They responded by beating him and breaking both his arms. “Did you complain to the authorities?” I asked him. He looked at me as if I had not understood what he had told me. If asking the simple question “Why?” of a police officer could result in a severe beating, did I not understand what complaining about police would do? Aphiwe was cared for by his friends who were also activists. They helped him get medical attention and kept him in the group while he recovered. This young man knew his town and understood the likelihood that a police complaint would result in further injury, or even worse consequences. Unlike some of us from more privileged communities, Aphiwe understood what it means to live with violence. As I was writing this chapter, I received the dreadful and tragic news that Aphiwe had been murdered. While I do not know the details, I was given to understand that his death was the result of a robbery gone terribly wrong. Aphiwe had only just learned that he had been accepted into a special program for talented young artists, likely the first person in his family to attend a post-secondary institution. His loss is immeasurable for his community, his family, and for his fellow activists. In all of the Tikkun study sites, we will continue to think about Aphiwe and mourn the loss we all feel for the brilliance he brought into our lives. I am an activist. I have spent much of my life enraged about injustice whenever and wherever I have seen it. Fortunately for me, I have been able to take action. I spent much of my life working for a non-government organization, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and Education Trust, that gave me the opportunity to create programmes for teachers, studentteachers, and for students from kindergarten through university. These programs encourage people to participate in their democratic communities. I believe that by asking pertinent questions, thinking critically, engaging in dialogue, and facing conflict, we can all learn to make a positive difference in our societies. I joined the Tikkun Youth Project as an activist and educator How Young People are Healing the World | 68 who wanted to find out more about the young people who have already learned to make a difference. What do they know about their rights? How do they experience their communities? What do prejudice and discrimination mean to them, and how do they approach injustice in their communities? I wanted to learn how the researchers and participants in the five sites of study would interact with one another, and how they could learn from their own research as well as from the experiences of others. I am a researcher in the sense that I learn from my observations and my readings, and while I am a teacher in that I engage with students, I am not an academic. I do not have a university appointment even though I have taught thousands of university students and teacher-candidates. My focus over the last three decades has been on citizenship education. I believe that as soon as a child is able to express an understanding of fairness (or of injustice), he or she is ready to take part as a citizen. I believe strongly in rights-based education and seek to identify strategies and information that can assist learners at all stages in seeing themselves as rights-holders. What follows below are my own observations and reflections on some of the stories reported and performed, and on research completed by the Tikkun Youth Project researchers and participants. We learned many poignant stories from the young people who participated in the Tikkun Youth Project’s Artnote. Below I share just a few as examples because there are so many such amazing stories. A young woman in Windsor told us that she became pregnant while still in school. She was faced with some deep and difficult choices: Would she be able to continue with her education? Could she manage motherhood and schooling at the same time? What would her family think? What kinds of stigma would she and her child face? What resources, if any, would be available to her in her community? Did she have the right to make demands on “the system?” She described how each of the choices open to her could lead down very different paths. Her acknowledgment of this conflict could be seen as the turning point where she moved from being acted upon by external forces, to being an actor – an activist who began to engage in her community at many levels. During the Artnote, we met a family that had fled for their lives from wartorn Syria. They shared their experiences about landing in Canada, knowing little or no English or French. These families had very little expectation of what, if any support their new community could provide. The children did not know if they would be able to go to school and whether they would be 69 | How Young People are Healing the World welcomed or rejected by other children. What would happen to the family if the adults were not able to find work? How would they live in this new land? While their English language skills are still limited, these young people have the courage to tell their stories to both newcomers and people whose families have lived in Canada for generations. As they shared their poignant stories of fear and uncertainties that have plagued their lives for many years, we learned about the effects of war and loss on youth and their families – and we could observe their determination to engage in positive ways with their new friends and community. So many times children and young activists are told by more senior members of their communities that they will be the leaders of the future. This chapter will demonstrate that young adult activists are at the forefront right now; they are not waiting to become more experienced or more educated – they are leading their communities now in ways that their seniors cannot even understand. What do these young leaders have in common and what are their differences? We will explore examples and stories about their involvement with what they identify as needs in their own lives and the lives of others. How have they done this? How do they facilitate change? Let’s see what their community participation and leadership look like on the ground. Identifying “Them” and “Us” One of the critical triggers that motivates youth to activism is the polarization of communities divided by strong social factors such as race, ethnicity, social class, and the lack of opportunity for employment and/or education. The manner in which a young person chooses to identify him/ herself is a significant contributor to the choices they make when faced with injustice. The civic engagement/pedagogy literature demonstrates that when young people learn to consider dissent and disagreement in a positive light, when they can listen to the views of people who think differently, they are better prepared to engage as citizens (Osborne, 2005; Sears, 2018). In each of the five Tikkun study sites, and in the wider context of their personal experiences, the young researchers have identified and come up against societal barriers to change. They have found that they themselves or How Young People are Healing the World | 70 others they know have faced unfairness and discrimination on a variety of grounds (Ontario Human Rights Commission, n.d.). Among the barriers faced by the young researchers in our studies are sexism, racism, bias against their religions, social class, the community with which they identify, and the neighbourhoods where they live. Most of the young people faced intersectional barriers because they are discriminated against on more than one ground. While the barriers are unique to each situation, the young people in our study share an optimism and an understanding that they are powerful. Their response to inequity has not been to sit back in fear; it has been to take charge. They believe Malala Yousafzai when she said, “When the world is silent, even one voice becomes powerful” (Yousafzai, 2013). Firstly, it must be said that young people throughout the world face discrimination and prejudice (Giroux, 2003; Pinker, 2012; Young-Breuhl, 2013; Youthism, n.d.). The very fact of their young age means that many adults believe a diminished number of years of experience makes young people less than competent to act in a responsible and capable fashion. ","PeriodicalId":291174,"journal":{"name":"Tikkun Beyond Borders: Connecting Youth Voices, Leading Change","volume":"116 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2019-09-09","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Tikkun Beyond Borders: Connecting Youth Voices, Leading Change","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.22329/digital-press.156.252","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
Young people everywhere face prejudice and discrimination. They are targeted for the same reasons older people are – because of their race, ethnicity, religion, gender, disability, or social status. They may live in societies where they face violence and deep personal strife. In addition to all of this, youth face the additional burden of discrimination on the grounds of their age. Most societies do not see young people as full citizens worthy of having a voice. Despite these barriers, the young people who participated in the Tikkun Youth Project, from five very disparate sites and demographics, demonstrated remarkable resilience, creativity, and willingness to engage with their communities. As an activist, I examined the civic engagement and rights-awareness of the young activist-researchers who appear in the international media, as well as those participating in the Tikkun Youth Project. I conclude, with some optimism, that young people are not waiting to become leaders: they are taking the reins and are making a positive difference – today. 67 | How Young People are Healing the World A young man named Aphiwe, who was from the community called Khayelitsha, an informal township in the South African city of Cape Town, told me a story. He was out for an evening with his friends. They were drinking beer (perhaps underage) in a hot and crowded venue when he decided to step outside for a breath of air, bringing his drink with him. As he was standing in front of the building, he was approached by several police officers. They told him it was illegal for him to be outside with his drink. He asked them why. They responded by beating him and breaking both his arms. “Did you complain to the authorities?” I asked him. He looked at me as if I had not understood what he had told me. If asking the simple question “Why?” of a police officer could result in a severe beating, did I not understand what complaining about police would do? Aphiwe was cared for by his friends who were also activists. They helped him get medical attention and kept him in the group while he recovered. This young man knew his town and understood the likelihood that a police complaint would result in further injury, or even worse consequences. Unlike some of us from more privileged communities, Aphiwe understood what it means to live with violence. As I was writing this chapter, I received the dreadful and tragic news that Aphiwe had been murdered. While I do not know the details, I was given to understand that his death was the result of a robbery gone terribly wrong. Aphiwe had only just learned that he had been accepted into a special program for talented young artists, likely the first person in his family to attend a post-secondary institution. His loss is immeasurable for his community, his family, and for his fellow activists. In all of the Tikkun study sites, we will continue to think about Aphiwe and mourn the loss we all feel for the brilliance he brought into our lives. I am an activist. I have spent much of my life enraged about injustice whenever and wherever I have seen it. Fortunately for me, I have been able to take action. I spent much of my life working for a non-government organization, the Canadian Civil Liberties Association and Education Trust, that gave me the opportunity to create programmes for teachers, studentteachers, and for students from kindergarten through university. These programs encourage people to participate in their democratic communities. I believe that by asking pertinent questions, thinking critically, engaging in dialogue, and facing conflict, we can all learn to make a positive difference in our societies. I joined the Tikkun Youth Project as an activist and educator How Young People are Healing the World | 68 who wanted to find out more about the young people who have already learned to make a difference. What do they know about their rights? How do they experience their communities? What do prejudice and discrimination mean to them, and how do they approach injustice in their communities? I wanted to learn how the researchers and participants in the five sites of study would interact with one another, and how they could learn from their own research as well as from the experiences of others. I am a researcher in the sense that I learn from my observations and my readings, and while I am a teacher in that I engage with students, I am not an academic. I do not have a university appointment even though I have taught thousands of university students and teacher-candidates. My focus over the last three decades has been on citizenship education. I believe that as soon as a child is able to express an understanding of fairness (or of injustice), he or she is ready to take part as a citizen. I believe strongly in rights-based education and seek to identify strategies and information that can assist learners at all stages in seeing themselves as rights-holders. What follows below are my own observations and reflections on some of the stories reported and performed, and on research completed by the Tikkun Youth Project researchers and participants. We learned many poignant stories from the young people who participated in the Tikkun Youth Project’s Artnote. Below I share just a few as examples because there are so many such amazing stories. A young woman in Windsor told us that she became pregnant while still in school. She was faced with some deep and difficult choices: Would she be able to continue with her education? Could she manage motherhood and schooling at the same time? What would her family think? What kinds of stigma would she and her child face? What resources, if any, would be available to her in her community? Did she have the right to make demands on “the system?” She described how each of the choices open to her could lead down very different paths. Her acknowledgment of this conflict could be seen as the turning point where she moved from being acted upon by external forces, to being an actor – an activist who began to engage in her community at many levels. During the Artnote, we met a family that had fled for their lives from wartorn Syria. They shared their experiences about landing in Canada, knowing little or no English or French. These families had very little expectation of what, if any support their new community could provide. The children did not know if they would be able to go to school and whether they would be 69 | How Young People are Healing the World welcomed or rejected by other children. What would happen to the family if the adults were not able to find work? How would they live in this new land? While their English language skills are still limited, these young people have the courage to tell their stories to both newcomers and people whose families have lived in Canada for generations. As they shared their poignant stories of fear and uncertainties that have plagued their lives for many years, we learned about the effects of war and loss on youth and their families – and we could observe their determination to engage in positive ways with their new friends and community. So many times children and young activists are told by more senior members of their communities that they will be the leaders of the future. This chapter will demonstrate that young adult activists are at the forefront right now; they are not waiting to become more experienced or more educated – they are leading their communities now in ways that their seniors cannot even understand. What do these young leaders have in common and what are their differences? We will explore examples and stories about their involvement with what they identify as needs in their own lives and the lives of others. How have they done this? How do they facilitate change? Let’s see what their community participation and leadership look like on the ground. Identifying “Them” and “Us” One of the critical triggers that motivates youth to activism is the polarization of communities divided by strong social factors such as race, ethnicity, social class, and the lack of opportunity for employment and/or education. The manner in which a young person chooses to identify him/ herself is a significant contributor to the choices they make when faced with injustice. The civic engagement/pedagogy literature demonstrates that when young people learn to consider dissent and disagreement in a positive light, when they can listen to the views of people who think differently, they are better prepared to engage as citizens (Osborne, 2005; Sears, 2018). In each of the five Tikkun study sites, and in the wider context of their personal experiences, the young researchers have identified and come up against societal barriers to change. They have found that they themselves or How Young People are Healing the World | 70 others they know have faced unfairness and discrimination on a variety of grounds (Ontario Human Rights Commission, n.d.). Among the barriers faced by the young researchers in our studies are sexism, racism, bias against their religions, social class, the community with which they identify, and the neighbourhoods where they live. Most of the young people faced intersectional barriers because they are discriminated against on more than one ground. While the barriers are unique to each situation, the young people in our study share an optimism and an understanding that they are powerful. Their response to inequity has not been to sit back in fear; it has been to take charge. They believe Malala Yousafzai when she said, “When the world is silent, even one voice becomes powerful” (Yousafzai, 2013). Firstly, it must be said that young people throughout the world face discrimination and prejudice (Giroux, 2003; Pinker, 2012; Young-Breuhl, 2013; Youthism, n.d.). The very fact of their young age means that many adults believe a diminished number of years of experience makes young people less than competent to act in a responsible and capable fashion.
以下是我对一些报道和表演的故事的观察和思考,以及Tikkun青年计划研究人员和参与者完成的研究。我们从参与Tikkun青年计划Artnote的年轻人那里了解到许多令人心酸的故事。下面我只分享几个例子,因为有很多这样令人惊奇的故事。温莎的一位年轻女子告诉我们,她还在上学的时候就怀孕了。她面临着一些深刻而艰难的选择:她能继续学业吗?她能同时兼顾做母亲和上学吗?她的家人会怎么想?她和她的孩子会面临什么样的耻辱?如果有的话,她在她的社区可以得到什么资源?她有权利向“体制”提出要求吗?她描述了摆在她面前的每一个选择如何引领她走上截然不同的道路。她对这一冲突的承认可以被看作是一个转折点,她从受外部力量影响转变为一名演员——一名开始在多个层面参与社区活动的活动家。在《艺术笔记》期间,我们遇到了一个从战火纷飞的叙利亚逃命的家庭。他们分享了在不懂英语或法语的情况下登陆加拿大的经历。这些家庭对他们的新社区能提供的支持几乎没有什么期望。孩子们不知道他们是否能够上学,也不知道他们是否会受到其他孩子的欢迎或拒绝。如果成年人找不到工作,这个家庭将会发生什么?他们将如何在这片新的土地上生活?虽然他们的英语水平仍然有限,但这些年轻人有勇气向新移民和世世代代居住在加拿大的人讲述他们的故事。当他们分享困扰他们多年的恐惧和不确定的痛苦故事时,我们了解了战争和损失对年轻人及其家庭的影响,我们可以看到他们决心以积极的方式与新朋友和社区交往。很多时候,儿童和年轻的活动人士被社区中更年长的成员告知,他们将成为未来的领导者。这一章将证明,年轻的成年活动家现在站在最前线;他们没有等待变得更有经验或受教育程度更高——他们现在正在以老年人甚至无法理解的方式领导他们的社区。这些年轻的领导人有什么共同之处,又有什么不同之处呢?我们将探索一些例子和故事,讲述他们在自己和他人的生活中所需要的东西。他们是怎么做到的?他们如何促进变革?让我们看看他们的社区参与和领导是什么样子的。识别“他们”和“我们”激励青年行动主义的一个关键触发因素是由种族、民族、社会阶层以及缺乏就业和/或教育机会等强烈社会因素造成的社区两极分化。年轻人在面对不公正待遇时选择自我认同的方式对他们做出的选择有重要影响。公民参与/教育学文献表明,当年轻人学会以积极的眼光看待不同意见和分歧时,当他们能够倾听持不同观点的人的观点时,他们就能更好地做好公民参与的准备(Osborne, 2005;西尔斯,2018)。在五个Tikkun研究地点中的每一个,以及在他们个人经历的更广泛背景下,年轻的研究人员都发现并克服了阻碍变革的社会障碍。他们发现,他们自己或《年轻人如何治愈世界》(How Young People are Healing the World | 70名他们认识的人)都面临着各种理由的不公平和歧视(安大略省人权委员会,n.d)。在我们的研究中,年轻研究人员面临的障碍包括性别歧视、种族主义、对他们的宗教、社会阶层、他们所认同的社区以及他们所居住的社区的偏见。大多数年轻人面临着交叉障碍,因为他们受到不止一种理由的歧视。虽然每种情况下的障碍都是独特的,但我们研究中的年轻人都持乐观态度,并认识到他们是强大的。他们对不平等的反应不是恐惧地坐着;它一直是负责任的。他们相信Malala Yousafzai所说的“当世界沉默时,即使一个声音也会变得强大”(Yousafzai, 2013)。首先,必须说的是,全世界的年轻人都面临歧视和偏见(吉鲁,2003;平克,2012;Young-Breuhl, 2013;Youthism,无日期)。