Development and Independent Validation of Energy Expenditure Models Using SmartStep

Abstract

In this work we developed and validated a method to capture the activities of daily living (ADL), transitions between ADL, and the associated Energy Expenditure (EE) using a novel insole based wearable system (SmartStep). A 15-participant study was conducted in a controlled laboratory environment while participants wore the SmartStep and performed various ADL. Machine learning models were developed using 4-branched and 8-branched steady-state activities to estimate the total energy expenditure (TEE) and physical activity energy expenditure (PAEE). Additional models accounting for transitions between activities were also developed. These models were validated in an independent study with 8-participants, performed in a whole room indirect calorimeter. In the controlled study, the 8-branched models had a lower root mean square error (RMSE, 0.58 vs. 0.67 kcal/min) and lower total error (−1.5% vs. 3%). In the validation study, the 8-branched models also had a lower RMSE (0.9 kcal/min vs. 1.2 kcal/min) and lower total error (−4.5% vs 11%). Accounting for activity transitions reduced the total error in the EE estimation to −1.3%. The results suggested that SmartStep can be used to accurately monitor the EE of the wearers in their daily living. The validation study results suggested that 8-branched models more accurately predict EE than 4-branched models and that accounting for activity transitions improves the estimation of EE in daily living.