북한의 관광정책 추진 동향과남북 관광협력에 대한 시사점 (The Trends of North Korean Tourism Policy and the Implications for Inter-Korean Cooperation)

Haejung Lee, Seonghwan Kim, S. Kang
{"title":"북한의 관광정책 추진 동향과남북 관광협력에 대한 시사점 (The Trends of North Korean Tourism Policy and the Implications for Inter-Korean Cooperation)","authors":"Haejung Lee, Seonghwan Kim, S. Kang","doi":"10.2139/ssrn.3710401","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"English Abstract: The trends of North Korean tourism policy and implications for inter-Korean cooperation Since Kim Jong-un has taken over as the leader of North Korea, North Korea has been pursuing aggressive and open tourism policies to secure stable means to earn foreign currency and improve its image. In March 2013, North Korea adopted a “Simultaneous Development Policy of Economy and Nuclear Weapons” at the 23rd Plenary Meeting of the 6th Central Committee of the Workers' Party of Korea and called for the revitalization of tourism by successfully creating various tourist areas, including the Wonsan and Chilbosan districts. The Five-Year Strategy for National Economic Development (2016–2020) announced at the 7th Congress of the Workers' Party of Korea in May 2016 also emphasized the operation of economic development zones and revitalization of the tourism sector. In particular, since 2016, economic sanctions by the international community have expanded and deepened, making it difficult for foreign currency to flow in through foreign trade, and North Korea has become more interested in the revitalization of the tourism industry, which can also contribute to the improvement of the national image while bypassing sanctions. As if to reflect this, Chairman Kim Jong-un's tours of tourist areas and on-site guidance of major tourism areas have increased from only twice in 2016 and once in 2017, to 10 in 2018 and 11 in 2019. The major tour areas include Samjiyon City, Yangdeok Hot Spring C lture Recreation Area, and Wonsan Galma Coast Tourism Area, which are classified as the top three tourist areas. Compared to other industries, the initial investment cost of the tourism industry is relatively lower, and if a certain level of infrastructure is secured, a reasonable amount of foreign currency can be earned stably. In the case of socialist transition countries such as Vietnam and Cuba, the acquisition of foreign currency through tourism at the beginning of the transition was used as a driving force for economic growth. North Korea is also believed to harbor intentions to earn foreign currency to restore its poor industrial base by invigorating the tourism industry using its relatively well-preserved natural environment. The nation is also attempting to break away from its closed-off image and create the image of a normal country through more active tourism policies than in the past. The tourism industry is relatively free from sanctions against North Korea by the international community, making it a promising channel for inflows of foreign currency while bypassing sanctions. Above all, Kim Jong-un has experience studying in Switzerland, which has a well-developed tourism sector, and seems to have been trying to fortify the economy and improve people's lives by revitalizing the tourism industry. This study analyzes the trends in tourism policy promotion in North Korea since Chairman Kim Jong-un took office in 2012, and promotes the New Northern Policy such as multilateral tourism cooperation including North and South and the New Economic Plan of the Korean Peninsula. The intention is to provide the necessary policy implications by grasping recent changes in North Korea's tourism policy, analyzing North Korea's policy intentions, and establishing concrete and feasible multilateral tourism cooperation plans including the two Koreas. Most notably, to promote individual tourism on a humanitarian level proposed by the government, as well as individual tourism via third countries through travel agencies of third countries, and individual tourism by foreigners in a form connecting the two Koreas, we have analyzed in detail the major North Korean tourism products currently being traded, and go on to derive important implications. Chapter 2 examined the changes in tourism policies in North Korea since Kim Jong-un took power as the leader of North Korea and analyzed perceptions of the tourism industry through North Korean literature. Amid international sanctions against North Korea due to the North Korean nuclear issue, North Korea is struggling to come up with measures to develop its economy by fostering its tourism industry. It was judged that the government is trying to boost the economy by revitalizing the construction industry and in particular the development of major tourism facilities, including the hot spring cultural resort in Yangdeok-gun, which was completed in 2019, the Wonsan Galma Coast Tourism Area, which is scheduled to be completed in 2020, and the construction of Samjiyon City. North Korea has been pushing forward with an all-round economic development zone policy, requiring 18 of the 28 economic development zones to include tourism development plans. In addition, the North Korean government has been showing its willingness to foster the tourism industry through the readjustment of tourism-related physical and human infrastructure. North Korean tourism products have diversified beyond the previous simple sightseeing tourism products to experience- and life-oriented tourism products, as the state becomes more active in promoting tourism to attract tourists. Due to the North Korean government's policy demand for tourism industry development, North Korea's tourism industry-related research has also increased significantly compared to previous times. Recently, North Korean academics are focusing on areas of interest such as exploring tourism industry development in line with trends in the world tourism market, attracting foreign capital through tourism development and eco-tourism development. Regarding he analysis of trends in the global tourism market, the recent development of information processing and information and communication technology (ICT) has led to a growing number of tourists calling for more convenient and comfortable trips, which provided a glimpse into North Korea's demand when looking at the possibility of promoting smart tourism between the two Koreas in the near future. To attract foreign investment through tourism development, tourism development areas are also strategically approached by dividing them into mountain tourism development areas and coastal tourism development areas, urban tourism development areas and rural tourism development areas, cultural and traditional tourism development areas, treatment tourism development areas, resting tourism development areas and comprehensive tourism development areas. Based on this analysis, It was judged that South Korea and North Korea have the potential to develop wellness tourism products using hot springs and forest resources across the country, as well as Korean traditional medicine, healing and meditation, and beauty spa facilities. To promote the development of eco-tourism sites, North Korea has analyzed the need for eco-tourism and emphasized the fundamental purpose of eco-tourism, and makes a particularly interesting claim that ecotourism is different from ordinary tourism and requires less investment in establishing tourism volunteer facilities. Our review also revealed the North should consider developing eco-tourism centers mainly in areas that could guarantee economic efficiency, such as the demilitarized zone (DMZ) and Mt. Geumgang. Chapter 3 examined the current state of the tourism industry in North Korea through tourism resources and infrastructure by region, promotion of tourism development projects since Kim Jong-un has taken over as the leader of North Korea, and analysis of tourism products in North Korea by overseas travel agencies. As a result, it was analyzed that the environment of the North Korean tourism industry will change as follows. First, the two pillars of the North Korean tourism industry are expected to be Pyongyang and Wonsan. As of 2020, most of the North Korean tourism products started in Pyongyang, where tourism resources and infrastructure were most concentrated, and ended in Pyongyang. It was analyzed that if the development of the Galma Coast tourism area in Wonsan is carried out smoothly, it will be possible to develop products that encompass the full scope of Pyongyang and Wonsan or Pyongyang and East Sea Coast area. Secondly, as of 2020, tourism to North Korea is only conducted in limited areas, but the open areas are expected to expand further in the near future. Areas that are likely to be further developed as conditions improve are analyzed as Gangnyeong, Sukcheon in the West Sea, Eorang in the East Sea, Sakju and Onseong in the northern part of the country. Third, North Korea's leisure sports and tourism products are expected to increase as well. Since the early days of the Kim Jong-un administration, the government has built or rebuilt recreational and tourism facilities where people can enjoy a variety of leisure activities. Overseas travel agencies are also selling products that allow them to enjoy the forest and marine leisure in the East Sea region. It was judged that North Korean authorities’ interest in leisure sports tourism will continue to expand. Finally, it was expected that tourism products will be developed in cooperation with the Northeast Asian region when domestic and international conditions improve. Overseas travel agencies sell tourism products in cooperation with South Korea, China and Russia to North Korea, and inter-Korean cooperation tourism is conducted using flights and cruise ships. It was analyzed that if tourism to Mt. Geumgang and Gaesong is resumed, various products will continue to be developed.","PeriodicalId":259955,"journal":{"name":"ERN: Open Macroeconomics in Transition Economics (Topic)","volume":"15 1","pages":"0"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2020-08-03","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"ERN: Open Macroeconomics in Transition Economics (Topic)","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.3710401","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

Abstract

English Abstract: The trends of North Korean tourism policy and implications for inter-Korean cooperation Since Kim Jong-un has taken over as the leader of North Korea, North Korea has been pursuing aggressive and open tourism policies to secure stable means to earn foreign currency and improve its image. In March 2013, North Korea adopted a “Simultaneous Development Policy of Economy and Nuclear Weapons” at the 23rd Plenary Meeting of the 6th Central Committee of the Workers' Party of Korea and called for the revitalization of tourism by successfully creating various tourist areas, including the Wonsan and Chilbosan districts. The Five-Year Strategy for National Economic Development (2016–2020) announced at the 7th Congress of the Workers' Party of Korea in May 2016 also emphasized the operation of economic development zones and revitalization of the tourism sector. In particular, since 2016, economic sanctions by the international community have expanded and deepened, making it difficult for foreign currency to flow in through foreign trade, and North Korea has become more interested in the revitalization of the tourism industry, which can also contribute to the improvement of the national image while bypassing sanctions. As if to reflect this, Chairman Kim Jong-un's tours of tourist areas and on-site guidance of major tourism areas have increased from only twice in 2016 and once in 2017, to 10 in 2018 and 11 in 2019. The major tour areas include Samjiyon City, Yangdeok Hot Spring C lture Recreation Area, and Wonsan Galma Coast Tourism Area, which are classified as the top three tourist areas. Compared to other industries, the initial investment cost of the tourism industry is relatively lower, and if a certain level of infrastructure is secured, a reasonable amount of foreign currency can be earned stably. In the case of socialist transition countries such as Vietnam and Cuba, the acquisition of foreign currency through tourism at the beginning of the transition was used as a driving force for economic growth. North Korea is also believed to harbor intentions to earn foreign currency to restore its poor industrial base by invigorating the tourism industry using its relatively well-preserved natural environment. The nation is also attempting to break away from its closed-off image and create the image of a normal country through more active tourism policies than in the past. The tourism industry is relatively free from sanctions against North Korea by the international community, making it a promising channel for inflows of foreign currency while bypassing sanctions. Above all, Kim Jong-un has experience studying in Switzerland, which has a well-developed tourism sector, and seems to have been trying to fortify the economy and improve people's lives by revitalizing the tourism industry. This study analyzes the trends in tourism policy promotion in North Korea since Chairman Kim Jong-un took office in 2012, and promotes the New Northern Policy such as multilateral tourism cooperation including North and South and the New Economic Plan of the Korean Peninsula. The intention is to provide the necessary policy implications by grasping recent changes in North Korea's tourism policy, analyzing North Korea's policy intentions, and establishing concrete and feasible multilateral tourism cooperation plans including the two Koreas. Most notably, to promote individual tourism on a humanitarian level proposed by the government, as well as individual tourism via third countries through travel agencies of third countries, and individual tourism by foreigners in a form connecting the two Koreas, we have analyzed in detail the major North Korean tourism products currently being traded, and go on to derive important implications. Chapter 2 examined the changes in tourism policies in North Korea since Kim Jong-un took power as the leader of North Korea and analyzed perceptions of the tourism industry through North Korean literature. Amid international sanctions against North Korea due to the North Korean nuclear issue, North Korea is struggling to come up with measures to develop its economy by fostering its tourism industry. It was judged that the government is trying to boost the economy by revitalizing the construction industry and in particular the development of major tourism facilities, including the hot spring cultural resort in Yangdeok-gun, which was completed in 2019, the Wonsan Galma Coast Tourism Area, which is scheduled to be completed in 2020, and the construction of Samjiyon City. North Korea has been pushing forward with an all-round economic development zone policy, requiring 18 of the 28 economic development zones to include tourism development plans. In addition, the North Korean government has been showing its willingness to foster the tourism industry through the readjustment of tourism-related physical and human infrastructure. North Korean tourism products have diversified beyond the previous simple sightseeing tourism products to experience- and life-oriented tourism products, as the state becomes more active in promoting tourism to attract tourists. Due to the North Korean government's policy demand for tourism industry development, North Korea's tourism industry-related research has also increased significantly compared to previous times. Recently, North Korean academics are focusing on areas of interest such as exploring tourism industry development in line with trends in the world tourism market, attracting foreign capital through tourism development and eco-tourism development. Regarding he analysis of trends in the global tourism market, the recent development of information processing and information and communication technology (ICT) has led to a growing number of tourists calling for more convenient and comfortable trips, which provided a glimpse into North Korea's demand when looking at the possibility of promoting smart tourism between the two Koreas in the near future. To attract foreign investment through tourism development, tourism development areas are also strategically approached by dividing them into mountain tourism development areas and coastal tourism development areas, urban tourism development areas and rural tourism development areas, cultural and traditional tourism development areas, treatment tourism development areas, resting tourism development areas and comprehensive tourism development areas. Based on this analysis, It was judged that South Korea and North Korea have the potential to develop wellness tourism products using hot springs and forest resources across the country, as well as Korean traditional medicine, healing and meditation, and beauty spa facilities. To promote the development of eco-tourism sites, North Korea has analyzed the need for eco-tourism and emphasized the fundamental purpose of eco-tourism, and makes a particularly interesting claim that ecotourism is different from ordinary tourism and requires less investment in establishing tourism volunteer facilities. Our review also revealed the North should consider developing eco-tourism centers mainly in areas that could guarantee economic efficiency, such as the demilitarized zone (DMZ) and Mt. Geumgang. Chapter 3 examined the current state of the tourism industry in North Korea through tourism resources and infrastructure by region, promotion of tourism development projects since Kim Jong-un has taken over as the leader of North Korea, and analysis of tourism products in North Korea by overseas travel agencies. As a result, it was analyzed that the environment of the North Korean tourism industry will change as follows. First, the two pillars of the North Korean tourism industry are expected to be Pyongyang and Wonsan. As of 2020, most of the North Korean tourism products started in Pyongyang, where tourism resources and infrastructure were most concentrated, and ended in Pyongyang. It was analyzed that if the development of the Galma Coast tourism area in Wonsan is carried out smoothly, it will be possible to develop products that encompass the full scope of Pyongyang and Wonsan or Pyongyang and East Sea Coast area. Secondly, as of 2020, tourism to North Korea is only conducted in limited areas, but the open areas are expected to expand further in the near future. Areas that are likely to be further developed as conditions improve are analyzed as Gangnyeong, Sukcheon in the West Sea, Eorang in the East Sea, Sakju and Onseong in the northern part of the country. Third, North Korea's leisure sports and tourism products are expected to increase as well. Since the early days of the Kim Jong-un administration, the government has built or rebuilt recreational and tourism facilities where people can enjoy a variety of leisure activities. Overseas travel agencies are also selling products that allow them to enjoy the forest and marine leisure in the East Sea region. It was judged that North Korean authorities’ interest in leisure sports tourism will continue to expand. Finally, it was expected that tourism products will be developed in cooperation with the Northeast Asian region when domestic and international conditions improve. Overseas travel agencies sell tourism products in cooperation with South Korea, China and Russia to North Korea, and inter-Korean cooperation tourism is conducted using flights and cruise ships. It was analyzed that if tourism to Mt. Geumgang and Gaesong is resumed, various products will continue to be developed.
(The Trends of North Korean Tourism Policy and The Implications for Inter-Korean Cooperation)
摘要:自金正恩成为朝鲜领导人以来,朝鲜一直奉行积极开放的旅游政策,以确保稳定的外汇收入和改善其形象。2013年3月,朝鲜在劳动党第6届中央委员会第23次全体会议上通过了《<s:2> - œSimultaneous经济与核武器发展政策<e:1>》,并要求通过成功创建元山、七宝山等多种旅游地区来振兴旅游业。2016年5月在朝鲜劳动党第七次代表大会上公布的《国家经济发展五年战略(2016<e:2> - 2020)》也强调了经济开发区的运作和旅游业的振兴。特别是2016年以来,国际社会的经济制裁不断扩大和深化,外汇难以通过对外贸易流入,朝鲜对振兴旅游业更加感兴趣,这也有助于在绕过制裁的同时改善国家形象。似乎是为了反映这一点,金正恩委员长的旅游区考察和重点旅游区现场指导,从2016年的2次、2017年的1次,增加到2018年的10次、2019年的11次。主要旅游地区有三池渊市、阳德温泉C文化游乐区、元山加尔马海岸旅游区等,被列为三大旅游地区。与其他行业相比,旅游业的初始投资成本相对较低,如果有一定的基础设施保障,可以稳定地赚取合理数额的外汇。在越南和古巴等社会主义转型国家,在转型之初通过旅游业获得外汇被用作经济增长的动力。据分析,北韩还想利用保存相对完好的自然环境,通过搞活旅游业,赚取外汇,以恢复落后的工业基础。韩国也试图通过比过去更积极的旅游政策,摆脱封闭的形象,塑造正常国家的形象。旅游产业相对不受国际社会对朝制裁的影响,是绕过制裁、流入外汇的好渠道。最重要的是,金正恩有在瑞士学习的经历,瑞士拥有发达的旅游业,他似乎一直在试图通过振兴旅游业来巩固经济,改善人民的生活。本研究分析了2012年金正恩主席上台以来朝鲜旅游政策推广的趋势,推动了包括南北在内的多边旅游合作和朝鲜半岛新经济计划等新北方政策。这是为了掌握最近北韩旅游政策的变化,分析北韩的政策意图,制定包括南北韩在内的具体可行的多边旅游合作计划,提供必要的政策启示。最值得注意的是,为了促进政府提出的人道主义层面的个人旅游,以及通过第三国旅行社通过第三国进行的个人旅游,以及以连接南北的形式进行的外国人个人旅游,我们详细分析了目前交易的主要朝鲜旅游产品,并得出了重要的启示。第二章考察了金正恩掌权以来朝鲜旅游政策的变化,并通过朝鲜文献分析了人们对旅游业的看法。在因北韩核问题而受到国际社会制裁的情况下,北韩正在努力制定通过培育旅游业来发展经济的方案。有分析认为,政府正在通过搞活建设产业,特别是开发2019年竣工的阳德郡温泉文化度假区、计划2020年竣工的元山葛玛海岸旅游区、三池渊市等主要旅游设施,来搞活经济。北韩要求28个经济开发区中的18个必须包含旅游开发计划,正在推进全面经济开发区政策。此外,北韩政府还通过调整与旅游相关的物质和人力基础设施,表明了培育旅游产业的意愿。 朝鲜的旅游产品已从以往单纯的观光旅游产品向体验型、生活型旅游产品转变,国家积极推进旅游,吸引游客。由于朝鲜政府对旅游业发展的政策需求,朝鲜与旅游业相关的研究也较以往显著增加。最近,北韩学术界正在研究顺应世界旅游市场趋势的旅游产业发展、通过旅游开发吸引外国资本、生态旅游开发等领域。从世界旅游市场趋势分析来看,随着信息处理技术(ICT)和信息通信技术(ICT)的发展,越来越多的游客要求更方便、更舒适的旅行,因此,考虑到南北智能旅游的可能性,可以看出北韩的需求。为了通过旅游开发吸引外资,还对旅游开发区域进行了战略处理,将其划分为山地旅游开发区域和沿海旅游开发区域、城市旅游开发区域和乡村旅游开发区域、文化和传统旅游开发区域、疗养旅游开发区域、休息旅游开发区域和综合旅游开发区域。据此分析,韩朝两国在利用全国各地的温泉和森林资源开发保健旅游产品方面具有潜力,而且还可以开发韩医、疗养、冥想、美容疗养设施等。北韩为了促进生态旅游场所的开发,分析了生态旅游的必要性,强调了生态旅游的根本目的,并提出了生态旅游与普通旅游不同,在建立旅游志愿设施方面投入较少的主张。研究结果还显示,北韩应该考虑在非军事区(DMZ)和金刚山等能保证经济效益的地区开发生态旅游中心。第三章通过分地区的旅游资源和基础设施、金正恩执政以来旅游开发项目的推进情况、海外旅行社对朝鲜旅游产品的分析,考察了朝鲜旅游业的现状。因此,有分析认为,北韩的旅游环境将发生如下变化。首先,平壤和元山将成为北韩旅游业的两大支柱。截至2020年,大部分朝鲜旅游产品从旅游资源和基础设施最集中的平壤开始,到平壤结束。据分析,如果元山加尔马海岸旅游区的开发顺利进行,将有可能开发出覆盖平壤-元山或平壤-东海地区的产品。第二,到2020年为止,到北韩旅游只在有限的地区进行,但预计在不久的将来,开放的地区将进一步扩大。据分析,随着条件的改善,有可能进一步开发的地区有江宁、西海淑川、东海严朗、北部的酒州、温泉等。第三,北韩的休闲、体育、旅游产品也有望增加。从金正恩执政初期开始,政府就修建或重建了娱乐和旅游设施,让人们可以享受各种休闲活动。海外旅行社也在销售可以在东海地区享受森林和海洋休闲的产品。据判断,朝鲜当局对休闲体育旅游的兴趣将继续扩大。最后,期待随着国内外条件的改善,与东北亚地区合作开发旅游产品。海外旅行社向朝鲜出售与韩国、中国、俄罗斯合作的旅游产品,并利用飞机和游轮进行南北合作旅游。据分析,如果恢复金刚山和开城旅游,将会继续开发各种产品。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
求助全文
约1分钟内获得全文 求助全文
来源期刊
自引率
0.00%
发文量
0
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信