A Weak Memory Model in Progvis: Verification and Improved Accuracy of Visualizations of Concurrent Programs to Aid Student Learning

Abstract

Previous research has shown that many students struggle with solving small concurrency problems after their first course on concurrency. A possible reason for this is that students do not have a suitable mental model of the semantics of the underlying programming language, and are therefore not able to properly reason about the program’s behavior. One way to help students learn concurrency and improve their mental model is through the use of visualization tools. Progvis is one such visualization tool that is not only aimed at concepts related to concurrency, but also provides an accurate visualization of more fundamental concepts to illustrate how they interact with concurrency. In previous work, the authors of Progvis performed a small-scale evaluation of the tool, and highlighted some areas of improvement. In this paper, we address these shortcomings by improving the memory model visualized by Progvis and implementing a model checker. We also evaluate Progvis on a larger scale by incorporating it into a course on concurrency and operating systems, which allows assessing whether using Progvis aids students in learning concurrency. The results indicate that Progvis (with our improvements) is successful in helping students realize how concurrency interacts with more fundamental concepts, and that students find it useful in helping them understand the content of the concurrency assignments.