A preliminary evaluation on the relationship among architectural and test smells

Abstract

Software maintenance is the software life cycle's longest and most challenging phase. Bad architectural decisions or sub-optimal solutions might lead to architectural erosion, i.e., the process that causes the system's architecture to deviate from its original design. The so-called architectural smells are the most common signs of architectural erosion. Architectural smells might affect several quality aspects of a software system, including testability. When a system is not prone to testing, sub-optimal solutions may be introduced in the test code, a.k.a. test smells. This paper explores the possible relations between architectural and test smells. By mining 798 releases of 40 open-source Java systems, we studied the correlation between class-level architectural and test smells. In particular, Eager Test and Assertion Roulette smells often occur in conjunction with Cyclically-dependent Modularization, Deficient Encapsulation, and Insufficient Encapsulation architectural smells.