A Systematic Review of Cultural Competence Trainings for Mental Health Providers.

Abstract

We conducted a systematic review to characterize features and evaluate outcomes of cultural competence trainings delivered to mental health providers. We reviewed 37 training curricula described in 40 articles published between 1984-2019 and extracted information about curricular content (e.g., cultural identities), as well as training features (e.g., duration), methods (e.g., instructional strategies), and outcomes (i.e., attitudes, knowledge, skills). Training participants included graduate students and practicing professionals from a range of disciplines. Few studies (7.1%) employed a randomized-controlled trial design, instead favoring single-group (61.9%) or quasi-experimental (31.0%) designs. Many curricula focused on race/ethnicity (64.9%), followed by sexual orientation (45.9%) and general multicultural identity (43.2%). Few curricula included other cultural categorizations such as religion (16.2%), immigration status (13.5%), or socioeconomic status (13.5%). Most curricula included topics of sociocultural information (89.2%) and identity (78.4%), but fewer included topics such as discrimination and prejudice (54.1%). Lectures (89.2%) and discussions (86.5%) were common instructional strategies, whereas opportunities for application of material were less common (e.g., clinical experience: 16.2%; modeling: 13.5%). Cultural attitudes were the most frequently assessed training outcome (89.2%), followed by knowledge (81.1%) and skills (67.6%). To advance the science and practice of cultural competence trainings, we recommend that future studies include control groups, pre- and post-training assessment, and multiple methods for measuring multiple training outcomes. We also recommend consideration of cultural categories that are less frequently represented, how curricula might develop culturally competent providers beyond any single cultural category, and how best to leverage active learning strategies to maximize the impact of trainings.