S. A. Arami, E. Alvandi, Mahtab Frootandanesh, N. Tahmasebipour, E. Sangchini
{"title":"运用模糊层次分析法对流域进行排序,以便实施行政管理措施","authors":"S. A. Arami, E. Alvandi, Mahtab Frootandanesh, N. Tahmasebipour, E. Sangchini","doi":"10.17099/JFFIU.16433","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process Abstract: Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures is necessary and inevitable. Determining areas of top priority for flood control projects is a managerial decision that should be approved by studies of physical, social and economic status of the region of interesrt and by assessing the outcomes of the past operations. Therefore, the aim of this research was to study morphological and physiographic characteristics, and to use geographic information systems (GIS) and multi-criteria decision-making methods (MCDM), to identify the critical sub-basins which have the tendency to be destructed, in Galikesh watershed, Golestan province. This watershed is important, yet critical, in terms of land use change, erosion and flooding in the Golestan Province, Iran. In total, nine morphological parameters were used to prioritize sub-watersheds using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP). The morphological parameters were by some means linked to watershed drainage system. Based on FAHP approach, sub-basins, as vulnerable zones, have been evaluated and cetegorized in five priority levels (very low, low, medium, high and very high levels). The results showed that 44.44% and 22.22% of sub-basins were categorized respectively under average, and high to very high levels, suggesting that the conservation and management measures are essential in order to maintain stability in the region. Thus, the FAHP technique is a practical and convenient method to show potential zones in order to implement effective management strategies, especially in areas where data availability is low and soil diversity is high. Finally, it can be said that without having to encounter high costs and a waste of time, sub-basins could be categorized by means of morphometric parameters in order to implement conservational measures to simutaneously conserve soil and the environment. Keywords: watersheds priority, FAHP, GIS, multi-criteria decision making, Galikesh watershed Su havzalarinda idari tedbirlerin bulanik analitik hiyerarsi yontemi kullanilarak onceliklendirilmesi Ozet: Idari tedbirleri gerceklestirmek icin havza onceliklendirilmesi gerekli ve kacinilmazdir. Taskin kontrolu projeleri icin oncelikli alanlari belirleme yonetimsel bir karardir ve bu karar; soz konusu bolgenin fiziksel, sosyal ve ekonomik statusu ile gecmisteki islemlerinin sonuclarini degerlendirerek alinmalidir. Bu nedenle, calismanin amaci cografi bilgi sistemleri (CBS) ve coklu kriterleri karar verme yontemleri (MCDM) kullanarak Gulistan eyaleti- Galikesh havzasinda tahrip edilme riski tasiyan havzalarin morfolojik ve fizyografik ozelliklerini incelemektir. Iran'in Gulistan Eyaleti icerisinde bulunan bu havza kritik bir sekilde erozyon ve taskin riski tasimaktadir. Toplamda, dokuz morfolojik parametre bulanik analitik hiyerarsi sureci (FAHP) icin kullanildi ve bu morfolojik parametreler havza drenaj sistemiyle dogrudan iliskiliydi. Bu yontemde alt havzalar; hassas bolgeler olarak, degerlendirilmis ve bes oncelik duzeyi (cok dusuk, dusuk, orta, yuksek ve cok yuksek seviyelere) seklinde kategorize edilmistir. Sonuclar; koruma ve alinacak yonetim tedbirlerinin bolgede istikrarin saglanmasi icin gerekli oldugunu gostermis; alt havzalarin sirasiyla % 44.44 oraninda ortalama altinda ve % 22.22 oraninda cok yuksek duzeyde korunmasi gerektigini vurgulamistir. Bulanik analitik hiyerarsi yontemi, ozellikle teknik veri kullanilabilirligi dusuk ve toprak cesitliligi yuksek olan bolgelerde, etkin yonetim stratejilerinin uygulanmasi icin potansiyel bolgeleri gosterme acisindan pratik ve kullanisli bir yontemdir. Son olarak, yuksek maliyetler ve zaman kaybi ile karsilasmaya gerek kalmadan, alt havzalar morfometrik parametreler kullanilarak toprak ve cevre korumasi acisindan kategorize edilebilmesini saglamaktadir. Anahtar Kelimeler: Su havzalari onceligi, FAHP, CBS, cok kriterli karar verme, Galikesh havzasi Received (Gelis): 28.01.2016 - Revised (Duzeltme): 17.02.2016 - Accepted (Kabul): 24.02.2016 Cite (Atif): Arami, S.A., Alvandi, E., Frootandanesh, M., Tahmasebipour, N., Sangchini, E.K., 2017. Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process. Journal of the Faculty of Forestry Istanbul University 67(1): 13-21. DOI: 10.17099/jffiu.16433","PeriodicalId":17682,"journal":{"name":"Journal of the Faculty of Forestry Istanbul University","volume":"2 1","pages":"13-21"},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2016-12-29","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"12","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process\",\"authors\":\"S. A. Arami, E. Alvandi, Mahtab Frootandanesh, N. Tahmasebipour, E. Sangchini\",\"doi\":\"10.17099/JFFIU.16433\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process Abstract: Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures is necessary and inevitable. Determining areas of top priority for flood control projects is a managerial decision that should be approved by studies of physical, social and economic status of the region of interesrt and by assessing the outcomes of the past operations. Therefore, the aim of this research was to study morphological and physiographic characteristics, and to use geographic information systems (GIS) and multi-criteria decision-making methods (MCDM), to identify the critical sub-basins which have the tendency to be destructed, in Galikesh watershed, Golestan province. This watershed is important, yet critical, in terms of land use change, erosion and flooding in the Golestan Province, Iran. In total, nine morphological parameters were used to prioritize sub-watersheds using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP). The morphological parameters were by some means linked to watershed drainage system. Based on FAHP approach, sub-basins, as vulnerable zones, have been evaluated and cetegorized in five priority levels (very low, low, medium, high and very high levels). The results showed that 44.44% and 22.22% of sub-basins were categorized respectively under average, and high to very high levels, suggesting that the conservation and management measures are essential in order to maintain stability in the region. Thus, the FAHP technique is a practical and convenient method to show potential zones in order to implement effective management strategies, especially in areas where data availability is low and soil diversity is high. Finally, it can be said that without having to encounter high costs and a waste of time, sub-basins could be categorized by means of morphometric parameters in order to implement conservational measures to simutaneously conserve soil and the environment. Keywords: watersheds priority, FAHP, GIS, multi-criteria decision making, Galikesh watershed Su havzalarinda idari tedbirlerin bulanik analitik hiyerarsi yontemi kullanilarak onceliklendirilmesi Ozet: Idari tedbirleri gerceklestirmek icin havza onceliklendirilmesi gerekli ve kacinilmazdir. Taskin kontrolu projeleri icin oncelikli alanlari belirleme yonetimsel bir karardir ve bu karar; soz konusu bolgenin fiziksel, sosyal ve ekonomik statusu ile gecmisteki islemlerinin sonuclarini degerlendirerek alinmalidir. Bu nedenle, calismanin amaci cografi bilgi sistemleri (CBS) ve coklu kriterleri karar verme yontemleri (MCDM) kullanarak Gulistan eyaleti- Galikesh havzasinda tahrip edilme riski tasiyan havzalarin morfolojik ve fizyografik ozelliklerini incelemektir. Iran'in Gulistan Eyaleti icerisinde bulunan bu havza kritik bir sekilde erozyon ve taskin riski tasimaktadir. Toplamda, dokuz morfolojik parametre bulanik analitik hiyerarsi sureci (FAHP) icin kullanildi ve bu morfolojik parametreler havza drenaj sistemiyle dogrudan iliskiliydi. Bu yontemde alt havzalar; hassas bolgeler olarak, degerlendirilmis ve bes oncelik duzeyi (cok dusuk, dusuk, orta, yuksek ve cok yuksek seviyelere) seklinde kategorize edilmistir. Sonuclar; koruma ve alinacak yonetim tedbirlerinin bolgede istikrarin saglanmasi icin gerekli oldugunu gostermis; alt havzalarin sirasiyla % 44.44 oraninda ortalama altinda ve % 22.22 oraninda cok yuksek duzeyde korunmasi gerektigini vurgulamistir. Bulanik analitik hiyerarsi yontemi, ozellikle teknik veri kullanilabilirligi dusuk ve toprak cesitliligi yuksek olan bolgelerde, etkin yonetim stratejilerinin uygulanmasi icin potansiyel bolgeleri gosterme acisindan pratik ve kullanisli bir yontemdir. Son olarak, yuksek maliyetler ve zaman kaybi ile karsilasmaya gerek kalmadan, alt havzalar morfometrik parametreler kullanilarak toprak ve cevre korumasi acisindan kategorize edilebilmesini saglamaktadir. Anahtar Kelimeler: Su havzalari onceligi, FAHP, CBS, cok kriterli karar verme, Galikesh havzasi Received (Gelis): 28.01.2016 - Revised (Duzeltme): 17.02.2016 - Accepted (Kabul): 24.02.2016 Cite (Atif): Arami, S.A., Alvandi, E., Frootandanesh, M., Tahmasebipour, N., Sangchini, E.K., 2017. Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process. Journal of the Faculty of Forestry Istanbul University 67(1): 13-21. DOI: 10.17099/jffiu.16433\",\"PeriodicalId\":17682,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Journal of the Faculty of Forestry Istanbul University\",\"volume\":\"2 1\",\"pages\":\"13-21\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2016-12-29\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"12\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Journal of the Faculty of Forestry Istanbul University\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.17099/JFFIU.16433\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of the Faculty of Forestry Istanbul University","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.17099/JFFIU.16433","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 12
摘要
摘要:流域行政措施优先排序是实施行政措施的必要和必然。确定防洪工程的最优先领域是一项管理决策,应该通过对有关地区的自然、社会和经济状况的研究以及对过去行动结果的评估来批准。因此,本研究的目的是研究Galikesh流域的形态和地理特征,并利用地理信息系统(GIS)和多准则决策方法(MCDM)识别具有破坏倾向的关键子流域。就伊朗戈列斯坦省的土地利用变化、侵蚀和洪水而言,这一分水岭很重要,但也很关键。采用模糊层次分析法(FAHP),利用9个形态参数对子流域进行排序。形态参数与流域排水系统有一定的联系。基于FAHP方法,对作为脆弱区的子流域进行了评价,并将其划分为5个优先级别(极低、低、中、高和极高)。结果表明,44.44%和22.22%的子流域被划分为“中等”和“高”至“非常高”级别,表明为保持区域稳定,必须采取保护管理措施。因此,FAHP技术是一种实用且方便的方法来显示潜在区域,以便实施有效的管理策略,特别是在数据可用性低和土壤多样性高的地区。最后,可以认为,在不产生高成本和浪费时间的情况下,利用形态计量参数对子流域进行分类,可以实施保护措施,同时保持土壤和环境。关键词:流域优先级,FAHP, GIS,多准则决策,Galikesh流域Su havzalarinda idarididbirlerin bulanik analyitik hierarsi yontemi kullanilak onceliklendirilmesi gereklive kacinilmazdir。任务控制系统是一种基于任务控制系统的系统,它可以使一个人对自己的行为进行控制。社会经济地位、社会经济地位、社会经济地位、社会经济地位、社会经济地位、社会经济地位、社会经济地位、社会经济地位、社会经济地位、社会经济地位。但针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针、针。伊朗的古利斯坦·埃利亚蒂(gullistan Eyaleti)在布隆迪境内进行了一项研究,但他批评说,这是一项危险的任务。结果表明,基于形态学参数的分析方法(FAHP)可以较好地解决上述问题,而基于形态学参数的分析方法则可以较好地解决这一问题。但是,你要做的一切都是有意义的。hasas bolgeler olarak, degerlendiilmis是一种有代表性的duzeyi (cok dusuk, dusuk, orta, yuksek, yuksek, seviyek)的seklinde分类edilmisir。Sonuclar;Koruma的一项研究表明,该研究的主要内容是:在一种特殊的环境中,在一种特殊的环境中,在一种特殊的环境中,在一种特殊的环境中。oraninda cok yuksek duzeyde korunmasi gerektigini vurgulamistir。布拉尼克的分析方法是:hiyerarsi yontemi, ozellike的分析方法是:veri kullanilabili的分析方法是:veri kullanilabili的分析方法是:veri kullanilabili的分析方法是:bolgelerde;Son olarak, yuksek maliyetler, zaman kaybi和karsilasmaya gerek kalmadan,以及havzalar形态测量参数测量器kullanilarak toprak,已经建立了korumasi acisdin和分类edilebilmesini saglamaktadir。anhtar Kelimeler: Su havzalari onceligi, FAHP, CBS, cok kriterli karar verme, Galikesh havzasi收稿(Gelis): 28.01.2016 -修订(Duzeltme): 17.02.2016 -接受(Kabul): 24.02.2016引用(Atif): Arami, S.A, Alvandi, E., Frootandanesh, M., Tahmasebipour, N., Sangchini, E.K, 2017。运用模糊层次分析法对流域进行排序,以便实施行政管理措施。伊斯坦布尔大学林业学院学报,67(1):13-21。DOI: 10.17099 / jffiu.16433
Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process
Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process Abstract: Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures is necessary and inevitable. Determining areas of top priority for flood control projects is a managerial decision that should be approved by studies of physical, social and economic status of the region of interesrt and by assessing the outcomes of the past operations. Therefore, the aim of this research was to study morphological and physiographic characteristics, and to use geographic information systems (GIS) and multi-criteria decision-making methods (MCDM), to identify the critical sub-basins which have the tendency to be destructed, in Galikesh watershed, Golestan province. This watershed is important, yet critical, in terms of land use change, erosion and flooding in the Golestan Province, Iran. In total, nine morphological parameters were used to prioritize sub-watersheds using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process (FAHP). The morphological parameters were by some means linked to watershed drainage system. Based on FAHP approach, sub-basins, as vulnerable zones, have been evaluated and cetegorized in five priority levels (very low, low, medium, high and very high levels). The results showed that 44.44% and 22.22% of sub-basins were categorized respectively under average, and high to very high levels, suggesting that the conservation and management measures are essential in order to maintain stability in the region. Thus, the FAHP technique is a practical and convenient method to show potential zones in order to implement effective management strategies, especially in areas where data availability is low and soil diversity is high. Finally, it can be said that without having to encounter high costs and a waste of time, sub-basins could be categorized by means of morphometric parameters in order to implement conservational measures to simutaneously conserve soil and the environment. Keywords: watersheds priority, FAHP, GIS, multi-criteria decision making, Galikesh watershed Su havzalarinda idari tedbirlerin bulanik analitik hiyerarsi yontemi kullanilarak onceliklendirilmesi Ozet: Idari tedbirleri gerceklestirmek icin havza onceliklendirilmesi gerekli ve kacinilmazdir. Taskin kontrolu projeleri icin oncelikli alanlari belirleme yonetimsel bir karardir ve bu karar; soz konusu bolgenin fiziksel, sosyal ve ekonomik statusu ile gecmisteki islemlerinin sonuclarini degerlendirerek alinmalidir. Bu nedenle, calismanin amaci cografi bilgi sistemleri (CBS) ve coklu kriterleri karar verme yontemleri (MCDM) kullanarak Gulistan eyaleti- Galikesh havzasinda tahrip edilme riski tasiyan havzalarin morfolojik ve fizyografik ozelliklerini incelemektir. Iran'in Gulistan Eyaleti icerisinde bulunan bu havza kritik bir sekilde erozyon ve taskin riski tasimaktadir. Toplamda, dokuz morfolojik parametre bulanik analitik hiyerarsi sureci (FAHP) icin kullanildi ve bu morfolojik parametreler havza drenaj sistemiyle dogrudan iliskiliydi. Bu yontemde alt havzalar; hassas bolgeler olarak, degerlendirilmis ve bes oncelik duzeyi (cok dusuk, dusuk, orta, yuksek ve cok yuksek seviyelere) seklinde kategorize edilmistir. Sonuclar; koruma ve alinacak yonetim tedbirlerinin bolgede istikrarin saglanmasi icin gerekli oldugunu gostermis; alt havzalarin sirasiyla % 44.44 oraninda ortalama altinda ve % 22.22 oraninda cok yuksek duzeyde korunmasi gerektigini vurgulamistir. Bulanik analitik hiyerarsi yontemi, ozellikle teknik veri kullanilabilirligi dusuk ve toprak cesitliligi yuksek olan bolgelerde, etkin yonetim stratejilerinin uygulanmasi icin potansiyel bolgeleri gosterme acisindan pratik ve kullanisli bir yontemdir. Son olarak, yuksek maliyetler ve zaman kaybi ile karsilasmaya gerek kalmadan, alt havzalar morfometrik parametreler kullanilarak toprak ve cevre korumasi acisindan kategorize edilebilmesini saglamaktadir. Anahtar Kelimeler: Su havzalari onceligi, FAHP, CBS, cok kriterli karar verme, Galikesh havzasi Received (Gelis): 28.01.2016 - Revised (Duzeltme): 17.02.2016 - Accepted (Kabul): 24.02.2016 Cite (Atif): Arami, S.A., Alvandi, E., Frootandanesh, M., Tahmasebipour, N., Sangchini, E.K., 2017. Prioritization of watersheds in order to perform administrative measures using fuzzy analytic hierarchy process. Journal of the Faculty of Forestry Istanbul University 67(1): 13-21. DOI: 10.17099/jffiu.16433