C. Kalva-Filho, L. Simieli, M. H. Faria, F. Barbieri
{"title":"信息图:改善帕金森病患者功能活动能力的四种训练方式","authors":"C. Kalva-Filho, L. Simieli, M. H. Faria, F. Barbieri","doi":"10.20338/bjmb.v16i1.284","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"Impairment of functional mobility is one of the most disabling symptoms in people with Parkinson’s disease (PwPD). Limitations in mobility lead to sedentarism, which may decrease the quality of life in PwPD. Several studies demonstrated that the combination of exercise with the traditional pharmacological treatment (i.e., levodopa) is effective to improve mobility in PwPD 1-5. Although the effects of traditional modalities (e.g., walking overground and cycling) are well documented, other stimuli may also induce positive responses on mobility in PwPD. However, such studies demonstrated trivial results or effectiveness in terms of functional mobility, indicating that the exercise – mainly using non-traditional stimuli – should be carefully prescribed. To avoid practical mistakes and ensure a high probability of success in mobility rehabilitation in PwPD, rehabilitation professionals must apply up-to-date and high-quality knowledge about mobility. Also, they must recognize the effects of different exercise modalities to improve functional mobility and the motivators and barriers to exercise in PwPD 1. This infographic aims to present (1) the motiving factors and barriers of training in PwPD, (2) the main effects of four exercise modalities on functional mobility (considering its underlining mechanisms), and (3) demonstrate the training evidence to improve the functional mobility.\nThe exercise modalities were selected from the four recent meta-analyses (searched on PUBMED) that tested the exercise effects on functional mobility and presented data related to exercise prescription for PwPD. The encouragement of other persons is the most motivating factor for PwPD during exercise. The lacking of encouragement, fatigue and depression are related to exercise barriers in PwPD 1. Suárez-Iglesias et al. 2 demonstrated that Pilates was effective to improve functional mobility, improving Timed Up and Go (TUG) performances. Interventions using hydrotherapy, with or without land-based therapy, also showed positive effects on TUG values 3. Dance modality, associated with auditory cues, promoted positive effects on gait velocity, TUG, and freezing of gait 4. Finally, Robinson et al. 5 observed that treadmill training, when compared to no-exercise ones, improved the gait velocity and step length in PwPD regardless of use or not body weight support. Overall these results were observed in patients with early to moderate stages of disease (Hoehn and Yahr < 3). These main effects and the mechanism related to the positive responses were presented in the infographic. \nDespite the noteworthy positive effects of exercise using these modalities in PwPD, recommendations for training prescriptions are still debatable. The characteristics of the modalities were poorly described in most of the studies. For example, even with the availability of acceptable and practical tools, the exercise intensity or its increment throughout the training was not properly reported. Therefore, it is difficult to determine a specific guideline to improve functional mobility in PwPD. The discussion about prescriptions (hydrotherapy) and the program with the highest weight in the meta-analysis (dance, pilates and treadmill) were presented in the infographic. Future studies should detail, as many as, possible training characteristics, increasing the reproducibility and applicability of the results.","PeriodicalId":91007,"journal":{"name":"Brazilian journal of motor behavior","volume":"71 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2022-03-01","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"Infographic: Four training modalities to improve functional mobility in people with Parkinson’s disease\",\"authors\":\"C. Kalva-Filho, L. Simieli, M. H. Faria, F. Barbieri\",\"doi\":\"10.20338/bjmb.v16i1.284\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"Impairment of functional mobility is one of the most disabling symptoms in people with Parkinson’s disease (PwPD). Limitations in mobility lead to sedentarism, which may decrease the quality of life in PwPD. Several studies demonstrated that the combination of exercise with the traditional pharmacological treatment (i.e., levodopa) is effective to improve mobility in PwPD 1-5. Although the effects of traditional modalities (e.g., walking overground and cycling) are well documented, other stimuli may also induce positive responses on mobility in PwPD. However, such studies demonstrated trivial results or effectiveness in terms of functional mobility, indicating that the exercise – mainly using non-traditional stimuli – should be carefully prescribed. To avoid practical mistakes and ensure a high probability of success in mobility rehabilitation in PwPD, rehabilitation professionals must apply up-to-date and high-quality knowledge about mobility. Also, they must recognize the effects of different exercise modalities to improve functional mobility and the motivators and barriers to exercise in PwPD 1. This infographic aims to present (1) the motiving factors and barriers of training in PwPD, (2) the main effects of four exercise modalities on functional mobility (considering its underlining mechanisms), and (3) demonstrate the training evidence to improve the functional mobility.\\nThe exercise modalities were selected from the four recent meta-analyses (searched on PUBMED) that tested the exercise effects on functional mobility and presented data related to exercise prescription for PwPD. The encouragement of other persons is the most motivating factor for PwPD during exercise. The lacking of encouragement, fatigue and depression are related to exercise barriers in PwPD 1. Suárez-Iglesias et al. 2 demonstrated that Pilates was effective to improve functional mobility, improving Timed Up and Go (TUG) performances. Interventions using hydrotherapy, with or without land-based therapy, also showed positive effects on TUG values 3. Dance modality, associated with auditory cues, promoted positive effects on gait velocity, TUG, and freezing of gait 4. Finally, Robinson et al. 5 observed that treadmill training, when compared to no-exercise ones, improved the gait velocity and step length in PwPD regardless of use or not body weight support. Overall these results were observed in patients with early to moderate stages of disease (Hoehn and Yahr < 3). These main effects and the mechanism related to the positive responses were presented in the infographic. \\nDespite the noteworthy positive effects of exercise using these modalities in PwPD, recommendations for training prescriptions are still debatable. The characteristics of the modalities were poorly described in most of the studies. For example, even with the availability of acceptable and practical tools, the exercise intensity or its increment throughout the training was not properly reported. Therefore, it is difficult to determine a specific guideline to improve functional mobility in PwPD. The discussion about prescriptions (hydrotherapy) and the program with the highest weight in the meta-analysis (dance, pilates and treadmill) were presented in the infographic. Future studies should detail, as many as, possible training characteristics, increasing the reproducibility and applicability of the results.\",\"PeriodicalId\":91007,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Brazilian journal of motor behavior\",\"volume\":\"71 1\",\"pages\":\"\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2022-03-01\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Brazilian journal of motor behavior\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.20338/bjmb.v16i1.284\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Brazilian journal of motor behavior","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.20338/bjmb.v16i1.284","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
摘要
功能活动障碍是帕金森病(PwPD)患者最严重的致残症状之一。行动能力的限制导致久坐,这可能会降低PwPD患者的生活质量。多项研究表明,运动与传统药物治疗(即左旋多巴)相结合可有效改善PwPD患者的活动能力1-5。虽然传统方式(如地上步行和骑自行车)的影响已被充分记录,但其他刺激也可能对PwPD患者的行动能力产生积极的反应。然而,这些研究在功能性活动方面显示了微不足道的结果或有效性,这表明这种主要使用非传统刺激的运动应该仔细规定。为避免实际错误,确保残疾人士的活动能力康复成功率高,康复专业人员必须运用最新的高质量的活动能力知识。此外,他们必须认识到不同的运动方式对改善功能活动能力的影响,以及PwPD 1中运动的动机和障碍。这张信息图旨在展示(1)PwPD训练的激励因素和障碍,(2)四种运动方式对功能活动能力的主要影响(考虑其主要机制),以及(3)展示训练改善功能活动能力的证据。运动模式是从最近的四项荟萃分析(PUBMED检索)中选择的,这些荟萃分析测试了运动对功能活动能力的影响,并提供了与PwPD运动处方相关的数据。他人的鼓励是PwPD在运动中最主要的诱因。缺乏鼓励、疲劳和抑郁与PwPD 1的运动障碍有关。Suárez-Iglesias等人2证明普拉提能有效改善功能活动能力,改善Timed Up and Go (TUG)表现。采用水疗法的干预措施,无论是否采用陆地疗法,对TUG值也显示出积极的影响。与听觉线索相关的舞蹈形式对步态速度、拖曳和步态冻结有积极影响。最后,Robinson等人5观察到,与不运动训练相比,无论是否使用体重支持,跑步机训练都能改善PwPD患者的步态速度和步长。总的来说,这些结果是在早期到中度疾病阶段的患者中观察到的(Hoehn和Yahr < 3)。这些主要作用和与积极反应相关的机制在信息图中给出。尽管在PwPD中使用这些方式的运动具有显著的积极作用,但对训练处方的建议仍存在争议。在大多数研究中,这些模式的特征描述得很差。例如,即使有了可接受和实用的工具,在整个训练过程中,运动强度或其增量也没有得到适当的报告。因此,很难确定一个具体的指导方针来改善PwPD的功能流动性。关于处方(水疗)和meta分析中权重最高的项目(舞蹈、普拉提和跑步机)的讨论显示在信息图中。未来的研究应尽可能详细说明训练特征,增加结果的可重复性和适用性。
Infographic: Four training modalities to improve functional mobility in people with Parkinson’s disease
Impairment of functional mobility is one of the most disabling symptoms in people with Parkinson’s disease (PwPD). Limitations in mobility lead to sedentarism, which may decrease the quality of life in PwPD. Several studies demonstrated that the combination of exercise with the traditional pharmacological treatment (i.e., levodopa) is effective to improve mobility in PwPD 1-5. Although the effects of traditional modalities (e.g., walking overground and cycling) are well documented, other stimuli may also induce positive responses on mobility in PwPD. However, such studies demonstrated trivial results or effectiveness in terms of functional mobility, indicating that the exercise – mainly using non-traditional stimuli – should be carefully prescribed. To avoid practical mistakes and ensure a high probability of success in mobility rehabilitation in PwPD, rehabilitation professionals must apply up-to-date and high-quality knowledge about mobility. Also, they must recognize the effects of different exercise modalities to improve functional mobility and the motivators and barriers to exercise in PwPD 1. This infographic aims to present (1) the motiving factors and barriers of training in PwPD, (2) the main effects of four exercise modalities on functional mobility (considering its underlining mechanisms), and (3) demonstrate the training evidence to improve the functional mobility.
The exercise modalities were selected from the four recent meta-analyses (searched on PUBMED) that tested the exercise effects on functional mobility and presented data related to exercise prescription for PwPD. The encouragement of other persons is the most motivating factor for PwPD during exercise. The lacking of encouragement, fatigue and depression are related to exercise barriers in PwPD 1. Suárez-Iglesias et al. 2 demonstrated that Pilates was effective to improve functional mobility, improving Timed Up and Go (TUG) performances. Interventions using hydrotherapy, with or without land-based therapy, also showed positive effects on TUG values 3. Dance modality, associated with auditory cues, promoted positive effects on gait velocity, TUG, and freezing of gait 4. Finally, Robinson et al. 5 observed that treadmill training, when compared to no-exercise ones, improved the gait velocity and step length in PwPD regardless of use or not body weight support. Overall these results were observed in patients with early to moderate stages of disease (Hoehn and Yahr < 3). These main effects and the mechanism related to the positive responses were presented in the infographic.
Despite the noteworthy positive effects of exercise using these modalities in PwPD, recommendations for training prescriptions are still debatable. The characteristics of the modalities were poorly described in most of the studies. For example, even with the availability of acceptable and practical tools, the exercise intensity or its increment throughout the training was not properly reported. Therefore, it is difficult to determine a specific guideline to improve functional mobility in PwPD. The discussion about prescriptions (hydrotherapy) and the program with the highest weight in the meta-analysis (dance, pilates and treadmill) were presented in the infographic. Future studies should detail, as many as, possible training characteristics, increasing the reproducibility and applicability of the results.