在奥尔比安合唱团的领土上埋葬«博利斯提尼»的宝藏:历史背景

Mykola Nikolaev
{"title":"在奥尔比安合唱团的领土上埋葬«博利斯提尼»的宝藏:历史背景","authors":"Mykola Nikolaev","doi":"10.31470/2616-6275-2021-5-59-80","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"The problem of the chronology of the Olbian «Borysthenes» still remains unsolved. To the greatest extent this applies to the date of the cessation of minting of these coins. Analysis of recent research and publications. Thus, according to A. N. Zograf, the last four lightweight groups of «Borysthenes» were minted in the 230 and 220 BC P. O. Karyshkovsky first attributed the completion of the minting of these coins to the 250 BC, later - until 240-230 BC. According to V. A. Anokhin, the minting of «Borysthenes» was completed in 280 BC. E. Ya. Turovsky attributes this event to 270 BC. e., and V. F. Stolba - until 275 BC. Our prosopographic study of differents of the «Borysthenes» of all groups (ie their interpretation by the names of real historical figures on the basis of a synchronized eponymous catalog), confirmed the previously proposed chronology and allowed to obtain a scheme that coincides with the scheme of P. O. Karyshkovsky on the first groups, and according to A. N. Zograf - in the chronology of the last four groups. According to our study, the minting of «Borysthenes» took place from 331-330 BC for at least 110 years with significant breaks; the completion of their issue dates back to 220-218 BC, or even to 217-216 BC. In general, the proposed model, both in terms of chronology and prosopography of coin magistrates, is a result of our basic research platform - synchronized eponymous catalog IPE I2 201 - and is a single interdependent system with lapidary inscriptions, graffiti, legends of agoranoms weights and ceramic inscriptions, magic lists, coin legends, etc. \nAt the same time, the treasures of the «Borysthenes» (which contain, in particular, coins of the later groups) have been published to date, connected with the collapse of the Olbia Chora, and their publishers date no later than 250-240 BC, or even 280 – 275 BC. In other cases, the dating of the treasures is tied to supposedly synchronous (300-275 BC) Pantikapaion coins, which are present together with «Borysthenes». Thus, significant chronological discrepancies were found between the dating of the «Borysthenes» treasures, which have been published in recent years, and the chronological model of minting we have built, which is part of a single chronological and prosopographic system of Olbia IV-I centuries BC. Accordingly, our proposed chronological model requires additional historical justification. The purpose of the paper is to study the chronology and historical circumstances of the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia in the III century BC, accompanied by a mass burying of the treasures of «Borysthenes». Research methodology – typical scientific methods in combination with the author’s own scientific work by synchronization of the eponyms catalogue IPE I2 201 (calendar) and Olbia’s prosopography, also, comparative paleography. Scientific novelty. On the basis of prosopography and comparative paleography, for the first time, a precision date of issuance of the IPE I2 32 decree in honor of Protogenes, (up to several years), was proposed. The date of the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia as a result of the invasion of the Scyros & Galatians, which was accompanied by a burying of the treasures of the «Borysthenes», has been clarified. The chronology of minting «Borysthenes», proposed by us in 2014–2020 through the study of their differents on the basis of synchronization of the eponymous catalog IPE I2 201, has been confirmed. Conclusions. 1. The traditional date dominates in science, of the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia (middle – beginning of the third quarter of the III century BC) established by V.V. Ruban on the basis of the chronological scheme of minting of «Borysthenes» of P. O. Karishkovsky (1968 year). At the same time, there are no other chronological indicators of the collapse of the Olbian Chora in the middle of the III century BC, in addition to the chronology of minting «Borysthenes» by P. O. Karyshkovsky. 2. Leading scholars have linked the demise of the Right Bank Chora to the invasion of the Scyros & Galatians, which is mentioned in decree IPE I2 32 in honor of Protogenes. Even in the time of V.V. Latyshev it is known that this decree is an absolute palaeographic analogue of the wall-building inscription IPE I2 180 of Cleombrot Pantaklus. According to the synchronization of the eponymous catalog IPE I2 201 Cleombrot Pantaclus performed eponymy in 222 BC. Thus, the dating of the decree in honor of Protogenes and the wall-building inscription of Cleombrot Pantaclus near to 222 BC. Both monuments describe the threat of the Scyros-Galatians invasion (inscription IPE I2 180 of Cleombrot Pantaklus – indirectly), which occurred several years later. Our proposed date of cessation of the minting of «Borysthenes» (220-218 BC or even 217-216 BC) for several years precedes the Scyros-Galatian invasion, respectively, in the treasures of «Borysthenes» there are coins and the last groups. Our main conclusion is that the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia and the hoarding of the treasures of the «Borysthenes» (with the latter groups inclusive) was caused by threat , mentioned in the decree in honor of Protogenes, which realised took place around the middle of the penultimate decade of the III century. BC (not the middle of the III century BC!) invasion of the Scyros-Galatians 3. The existence of treasures formed from «Borysthenes» mainly of the first group, confirms the existence of a chronological break in the minting of the first and second groups. 4. The presence of silver stators of the late IV century. BC as part of the treasure of «Borysthenes» is not a chronological indicator, but only evidence of their circulation until the penultimate decade of the III century BC, (as believe by P.O. Karishkovsky). 5. The presence of coins of Pantikapaion of the end of IV - the first quarter of III century BC in some treasures of «Borysthenes» is not a chronological indicator. These coins were in circulation for at least 250 years until the time of Mithridates VI of Eupator. 6. Finds of «Borysthenes» treasures on the territory or district of a settlement are not unambiguous evidence of the date of their hoarding on the date of collapse of this settlement. In particular, the treasures of the «Borysthenes», hoarded near the crossings (Kapulivka, Ruska Kosa) date near to 215 BC, (not 275 BC, according to their publishers). 7. Icreased wear of coins of early groups in treasures in comparison with the new state of «Borysthenes» of the last groups (see, for example, treasures from Kapulivka, Ruska Kosa), testifies to duration of process of issue of «Borysthenes».","PeriodicalId":33264,"journal":{"name":"Ukrayins''kii numizmatichnii shchorichnik","volume":" ","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":0.0000,"publicationDate":"2021-12-30","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":"{\"title\":\"THE BURYING OF TREASURES OF «BORYSTHENES» ON THE TERRITORY OF THE OLBIAN CHORA: THE HISTORICAL CONTEXT\",\"authors\":\"Mykola Nikolaev\",\"doi\":\"10.31470/2616-6275-2021-5-59-80\",\"DOIUrl\":null,\"url\":null,\"abstract\":\"The problem of the chronology of the Olbian «Borysthenes» still remains unsolved. To the greatest extent this applies to the date of the cessation of minting of these coins. Analysis of recent research and publications. Thus, according to A. N. Zograf, the last four lightweight groups of «Borysthenes» were minted in the 230 and 220 BC P. O. Karyshkovsky first attributed the completion of the minting of these coins to the 250 BC, later - until 240-230 BC. According to V. A. Anokhin, the minting of «Borysthenes» was completed in 280 BC. E. Ya. Turovsky attributes this event to 270 BC. e., and V. F. Stolba - until 275 BC. Our prosopographic study of differents of the «Borysthenes» of all groups (ie their interpretation by the names of real historical figures on the basis of a synchronized eponymous catalog), confirmed the previously proposed chronology and allowed to obtain a scheme that coincides with the scheme of P. O. Karyshkovsky on the first groups, and according to A. N. Zograf - in the chronology of the last four groups. According to our study, the minting of «Borysthenes» took place from 331-330 BC for at least 110 years with significant breaks; the completion of their issue dates back to 220-218 BC, or even to 217-216 BC. In general, the proposed model, both in terms of chronology and prosopography of coin magistrates, is a result of our basic research platform - synchronized eponymous catalog IPE I2 201 - and is a single interdependent system with lapidary inscriptions, graffiti, legends of agoranoms weights and ceramic inscriptions, magic lists, coin legends, etc. \\nAt the same time, the treasures of the «Borysthenes» (which contain, in particular, coins of the later groups) have been published to date, connected with the collapse of the Olbia Chora, and their publishers date no later than 250-240 BC, or even 280 – 275 BC. In other cases, the dating of the treasures is tied to supposedly synchronous (300-275 BC) Pantikapaion coins, which are present together with «Borysthenes». Thus, significant chronological discrepancies were found between the dating of the «Borysthenes» treasures, which have been published in recent years, and the chronological model of minting we have built, which is part of a single chronological and prosopographic system of Olbia IV-I centuries BC. Accordingly, our proposed chronological model requires additional historical justification. The purpose of the paper is to study the chronology and historical circumstances of the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia in the III century BC, accompanied by a mass burying of the treasures of «Borysthenes». Research methodology – typical scientific methods in combination with the author’s own scientific work by synchronization of the eponyms catalogue IPE I2 201 (calendar) and Olbia’s prosopography, also, comparative paleography. Scientific novelty. On the basis of prosopography and comparative paleography, for the first time, a precision date of issuance of the IPE I2 32 decree in honor of Protogenes, (up to several years), was proposed. The date of the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia as a result of the invasion of the Scyros & Galatians, which was accompanied by a burying of the treasures of the «Borysthenes», has been clarified. The chronology of minting «Borysthenes», proposed by us in 2014–2020 through the study of their differents on the basis of synchronization of the eponymous catalog IPE I2 201, has been confirmed. Conclusions. 1. The traditional date dominates in science, of the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia (middle – beginning of the third quarter of the III century BC) established by V.V. Ruban on the basis of the chronological scheme of minting of «Borysthenes» of P. O. Karishkovsky (1968 year). At the same time, there are no other chronological indicators of the collapse of the Olbian Chora in the middle of the III century BC, in addition to the chronology of minting «Borysthenes» by P. O. Karyshkovsky. 2. Leading scholars have linked the demise of the Right Bank Chora to the invasion of the Scyros & Galatians, which is mentioned in decree IPE I2 32 in honor of Protogenes. Even in the time of V.V. Latyshev it is known that this decree is an absolute palaeographic analogue of the wall-building inscription IPE I2 180 of Cleombrot Pantaklus. According to the synchronization of the eponymous catalog IPE I2 201 Cleombrot Pantaclus performed eponymy in 222 BC. Thus, the dating of the decree in honor of Protogenes and the wall-building inscription of Cleombrot Pantaclus near to 222 BC. Both monuments describe the threat of the Scyros-Galatians invasion (inscription IPE I2 180 of Cleombrot Pantaklus – indirectly), which occurred several years later. Our proposed date of cessation of the minting of «Borysthenes» (220-218 BC or even 217-216 BC) for several years precedes the Scyros-Galatian invasion, respectively, in the treasures of «Borysthenes» there are coins and the last groups. Our main conclusion is that the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia and the hoarding of the treasures of the «Borysthenes» (with the latter groups inclusive) was caused by threat , mentioned in the decree in honor of Protogenes, which realised took place around the middle of the penultimate decade of the III century. BC (not the middle of the III century BC!) invasion of the Scyros-Galatians 3. The existence of treasures formed from «Borysthenes» mainly of the first group, confirms the existence of a chronological break in the minting of the first and second groups. 4. The presence of silver stators of the late IV century. BC as part of the treasure of «Borysthenes» is not a chronological indicator, but only evidence of their circulation until the penultimate decade of the III century BC, (as believe by P.O. Karishkovsky). 5. The presence of coins of Pantikapaion of the end of IV - the first quarter of III century BC in some treasures of «Borysthenes» is not a chronological indicator. These coins were in circulation for at least 250 years until the time of Mithridates VI of Eupator. 6. Finds of «Borysthenes» treasures on the territory or district of a settlement are not unambiguous evidence of the date of their hoarding on the date of collapse of this settlement. In particular, the treasures of the «Borysthenes», hoarded near the crossings (Kapulivka, Ruska Kosa) date near to 215 BC, (not 275 BC, according to their publishers). 7. Icreased wear of coins of early groups in treasures in comparison with the new state of «Borysthenes» of the last groups (see, for example, treasures from Kapulivka, Ruska Kosa), testifies to duration of process of issue of «Borysthenes».\",\"PeriodicalId\":33264,\"journal\":{\"name\":\"Ukrayins''kii numizmatichnii shchorichnik\",\"volume\":\" \",\"pages\":\"\"},\"PeriodicalIF\":0.0000,\"publicationDate\":\"2021-12-30\",\"publicationTypes\":\"Journal Article\",\"fieldsOfStudy\":null,\"isOpenAccess\":false,\"openAccessPdf\":\"\",\"citationCount\":\"0\",\"resultStr\":null,\"platform\":\"Semanticscholar\",\"paperid\":null,\"PeriodicalName\":\"Ukrayins''kii numizmatichnii shchorichnik\",\"FirstCategoryId\":\"1085\",\"ListUrlMain\":\"https://doi.org/10.31470/2616-6275-2021-5-59-80\",\"RegionNum\":0,\"RegionCategory\":null,\"ArticlePicture\":[],\"TitleCN\":null,\"AbstractTextCN\":null,\"PMCID\":null,\"EPubDate\":\"\",\"PubModel\":\"\",\"JCR\":\"\",\"JCRName\":\"\",\"Score\":null,\"Total\":0}","platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Ukrayins''kii numizmatichnii shchorichnik","FirstCategoryId":"1085","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.31470/2616-6275-2021-5-59-80","RegionNum":0,"RegionCategory":null,"ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"","JCRName":"","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0

摘要

奥尔比安“鲍里斯提尼”的年代问题仍然没有解决。这在最大程度上适用于停止铸造这些硬币的日期。分析最近的研究和出版物。因此,根据A. N. Zograf的说法,最后四组轻量级的“鲍里斯提尼”是在公元前230年和220年铸造的,P. O. Karyshkovsky首先将这些硬币的铸造完成归因于公元前250年,后来-直到公元前240-230年。根据V. A. Anokhin的说法,“Borysthenes”的铸造完成于公元前280年。大肠丫。图洛夫斯基认为这件事发生在公元前270年。和斯托尔巴——直到公元前275年。我们对所有群体中不同的“鲍里斯提尼”的外形研究(即根据同步同名目录的真实历史人物的名字进行解释),证实了先前提出的年表,并允许获得与P. O. Karyshkovsky在第一个群体中的方案相一致的方案,并根据a . N. Zograf -在最后四个群体的年表中。根据我们的研究,“鲍里斯提尼”的铸造发生在公元前331-330年间,至少持续了110年,其间有明显的中断;它们的发行完成可以追溯到公元前220-218年,甚至公元前217-216年。总的来说,所提出的模型,无论是在钱币地方官的年表方面,还是在钱币地方官的方位学方面,都是我们的基础研究平台——同步同名目录IPE i2201——的结果,并且是一个单一的相互依存的系统,其中包括石刻铭文、涂鸦、agoranoms重量传说和陶瓷铭文、魔法清单、钱币传说等。与此同时,“博利斯提尼”的宝藏(特别是包含后来群体的硬币)已经出版至今,与奥尔比亚乔拉的崩溃有关,他们的出版商日期不迟于公元前250-240年,甚至公元前280 - 275年。在其他情况下,这些宝藏的年代与可能同步(公元前300-275年)的Pantikapaion硬币有关,这些硬币与“Borysthenes”一起出现。因此,在近年来出版的“鲍里斯提尼”宝藏的年代与我们建立的铸造时间模型之间发现了重大的时间差异,这是公元前4 - 1世纪奥尔比亚单一时间和结构系统的一部分。因此,我们提出的时间顺序模型需要额外的历史依据。本文的目的是研究公元前三世纪奥尔比亚右岸乔拉崩溃的年表和历史环境,伴随着“鲍里斯提尼”宝藏的大规模埋葬。研究方法-典型的科学方法结合作者自己的科学工作,通过同步命名目录IPE i2201(日历)和Olbia的人物学,也比较古文献学。科学的新奇。在形体学和比较古文献学的基础上,首次提出了纪念原基因的IPE i232法令颁布的精确日期(最多可达几年)。由于斯基罗斯和加拉太人的入侵,奥尔比亚右岸乔拉崩溃的日期已经得到澄清,同时还埋葬了“鲍里斯提尼”的宝藏。我们在同名目录IPE i2201同步的基础上,通过对它们的差异进行研究,提出了2014-2020年铸造«Borysthenes»的年表,已经得到确认。结论:1。传统的日期在科学上占主导地位,奥尔比亚右岸的崩溃(公元前三世纪第三季度中期-开始)由V.V. Ruban根据P. O. Karishkovsky(1968年)的“Borysthenes”铸造的时间顺序计划建立。与此同时,除了P. O. Karyshkovsky的铸造“Borysthenes”的年表外,没有其他时间指标表明公元前三世纪中叶奥尔比安Chora的崩溃。著名学者将右岸乔拉的灭亡与西克罗斯和加拉太人的入侵联系在一起,这是在纪念Protogenes的法令IPE i232中提到的。即使在V.V. Latyshev时代,人们也知道,这条法令绝对是Cleombrot Pantaklus的城墙建筑铭文IPE i2180的古摹本。根据同名目录IPE i2201的同步,Cleombrot Pantaclus在公元前222年进行了同名。因此,在公元前222年左右,为纪念Protogenes而颁布的法令和Cleombrot Pantaclus的城墙建筑铭文的年代。两座纪念碑都描述了几年后发生的塞古罗斯-加拉太人入侵的威胁(Cleombrot Pantaklus的铭文IPE i2180 -间接)。我们提出的停止“鲍里斯提尼”铸造的日期(公元前220-218年,甚至公元前217-216年)分别比斯克罗斯-加拉太入侵早几年,在“鲍里斯提尼”的宝藏中有硬币和最后一批。 我们的主要结论是,奥尔比亚右岸Chora的崩溃和“Borysthenes”宝藏的囤积(包括后一组)是由威胁引起的,在纪念Protogenes的法令中提到,这发生在三世纪倒数第二个十年的中期。公元前(不是公元前三世纪中叶!)入侵塞古罗-加拉太人。主要由第一组的“鲍里斯提尼”形成的宝藏的存在,证实了第一组和第二组铸造的时间顺序中断的存在。4. 四世纪晚期银制定子的出现。公元前作为“鲍里斯提尼”宝藏的一部分并不是一个时间顺序的指标,而只是它们流通的证据,直到公元前三世纪的倒数第二个十年,(由P.O. Karishkovsky相信)。5. 在“博利斯尼”的一些宝藏中,出现了公元前四世纪末-公元前三世纪前四分之一的潘提卡帕翁硬币,这并不是一个时间顺序的指标。这些硬币至少流通了250年,直到尤普托的米特拉达梯六世时代。在一个定居点的领土或地区发现的“鲍里斯提尼”宝藏,并不是明确的证据,表明他们的囤积日期是在这个定居点崩溃的日期。特别是藏在十字路口(卡普利夫卡,鲁斯卡科萨)附近的“鲍里斯特尼”宝藏,可以追溯到公元前215年(根据出版商的说法,不是公元前275年)。7. 与最后一批的“鲍里斯提尼”的新状态相比,早期群体在宝藏中增加了硬币的磨损(例如,参见卡普利夫卡,鲁斯卡科萨的宝藏),证明了“鲍里斯提尼”发行过程的持续时间。
本文章由计算机程序翻译,如有差异,请以英文原文为准。
THE BURYING OF TREASURES OF «BORYSTHENES» ON THE TERRITORY OF THE OLBIAN CHORA: THE HISTORICAL CONTEXT
The problem of the chronology of the Olbian «Borysthenes» still remains unsolved. To the greatest extent this applies to the date of the cessation of minting of these coins. Analysis of recent research and publications. Thus, according to A. N. Zograf, the last four lightweight groups of «Borysthenes» were minted in the 230 and 220 BC P. O. Karyshkovsky first attributed the completion of the minting of these coins to the 250 BC, later - until 240-230 BC. According to V. A. Anokhin, the minting of «Borysthenes» was completed in 280 BC. E. Ya. Turovsky attributes this event to 270 BC. e., and V. F. Stolba - until 275 BC. Our prosopographic study of differents of the «Borysthenes» of all groups (ie their interpretation by the names of real historical figures on the basis of a synchronized eponymous catalog), confirmed the previously proposed chronology and allowed to obtain a scheme that coincides with the scheme of P. O. Karyshkovsky on the first groups, and according to A. N. Zograf - in the chronology of the last four groups. According to our study, the minting of «Borysthenes» took place from 331-330 BC for at least 110 years with significant breaks; the completion of their issue dates back to 220-218 BC, or even to 217-216 BC. In general, the proposed model, both in terms of chronology and prosopography of coin magistrates, is a result of our basic research platform - synchronized eponymous catalog IPE I2 201 - and is a single interdependent system with lapidary inscriptions, graffiti, legends of agoranoms weights and ceramic inscriptions, magic lists, coin legends, etc. At the same time, the treasures of the «Borysthenes» (which contain, in particular, coins of the later groups) have been published to date, connected with the collapse of the Olbia Chora, and their publishers date no later than 250-240 BC, or even 280 – 275 BC. In other cases, the dating of the treasures is tied to supposedly synchronous (300-275 BC) Pantikapaion coins, which are present together with «Borysthenes». Thus, significant chronological discrepancies were found between the dating of the «Borysthenes» treasures, which have been published in recent years, and the chronological model of minting we have built, which is part of a single chronological and prosopographic system of Olbia IV-I centuries BC. Accordingly, our proposed chronological model requires additional historical justification. The purpose of the paper is to study the chronology and historical circumstances of the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia in the III century BC, accompanied by a mass burying of the treasures of «Borysthenes». Research methodology – typical scientific methods in combination with the author’s own scientific work by synchronization of the eponyms catalogue IPE I2 201 (calendar) and Olbia’s prosopography, also, comparative paleography. Scientific novelty. On the basis of prosopography and comparative paleography, for the first time, a precision date of issuance of the IPE I2 32 decree in honor of Protogenes, (up to several years), was proposed. The date of the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia as a result of the invasion of the Scyros & Galatians, which was accompanied by a burying of the treasures of the «Borysthenes», has been clarified. The chronology of minting «Borysthenes», proposed by us in 2014–2020 through the study of their differents on the basis of synchronization of the eponymous catalog IPE I2 201, has been confirmed. Conclusions. 1. The traditional date dominates in science, of the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia (middle – beginning of the third quarter of the III century BC) established by V.V. Ruban on the basis of the chronological scheme of minting of «Borysthenes» of P. O. Karishkovsky (1968 year). At the same time, there are no other chronological indicators of the collapse of the Olbian Chora in the middle of the III century BC, in addition to the chronology of minting «Borysthenes» by P. O. Karyshkovsky. 2. Leading scholars have linked the demise of the Right Bank Chora to the invasion of the Scyros & Galatians, which is mentioned in decree IPE I2 32 in honor of Protogenes. Even in the time of V.V. Latyshev it is known that this decree is an absolute palaeographic analogue of the wall-building inscription IPE I2 180 of Cleombrot Pantaklus. According to the synchronization of the eponymous catalog IPE I2 201 Cleombrot Pantaclus performed eponymy in 222 BC. Thus, the dating of the decree in honor of Protogenes and the wall-building inscription of Cleombrot Pantaclus near to 222 BC. Both monuments describe the threat of the Scyros-Galatians invasion (inscription IPE I2 180 of Cleombrot Pantaklus – indirectly), which occurred several years later. Our proposed date of cessation of the minting of «Borysthenes» (220-218 BC or even 217-216 BC) for several years precedes the Scyros-Galatian invasion, respectively, in the treasures of «Borysthenes» there are coins and the last groups. Our main conclusion is that the collapse of the Right Bank Chora of Olbia and the hoarding of the treasures of the «Borysthenes» (with the latter groups inclusive) was caused by threat , mentioned in the decree in honor of Protogenes, which realised took place around the middle of the penultimate decade of the III century. BC (not the middle of the III century BC!) invasion of the Scyros-Galatians 3. The existence of treasures formed from «Borysthenes» mainly of the first group, confirms the existence of a chronological break in the minting of the first and second groups. 4. The presence of silver stators of the late IV century. BC as part of the treasure of «Borysthenes» is not a chronological indicator, but only evidence of their circulation until the penultimate decade of the III century BC, (as believe by P.O. Karishkovsky). 5. The presence of coins of Pantikapaion of the end of IV - the first quarter of III century BC in some treasures of «Borysthenes» is not a chronological indicator. These coins were in circulation for at least 250 years until the time of Mithridates VI of Eupator. 6. Finds of «Borysthenes» treasures on the territory or district of a settlement are not unambiguous evidence of the date of their hoarding on the date of collapse of this settlement. In particular, the treasures of the «Borysthenes», hoarded near the crossings (Kapulivka, Ruska Kosa) date near to 215 BC, (not 275 BC, according to their publishers). 7. Icreased wear of coins of early groups in treasures in comparison with the new state of «Borysthenes» of the last groups (see, for example, treasures from Kapulivka, Ruska Kosa), testifies to duration of process of issue of «Borysthenes».
求助全文
通过发布文献求助,成功后即可免费获取论文全文。 去求助
来源期刊
CiteScore
0.20
自引率
0.00%
发文量
19
审稿时长
20 weeks
×
引用
GB/T 7714-2015
复制
MLA
复制
APA
复制
导出至
BibTeX EndNote RefMan NoteFirst NoteExpress
×
提示
您的信息不完整,为了账户安全,请先补充。
现在去补充
×
提示
您因"违规操作"
具体请查看互助需知
我知道了
×
提示
确定
请完成安全验证×
copy
已复制链接
快去分享给好友吧!
我知道了
右上角分享
点击右上角分享
0
联系我们:info@booksci.cn Book学术提供免费学术资源搜索服务,方便国内外学者检索中英文文献。致力于提供最便捷和优质的服务体验。 Copyright © 2023 布克学术 All rights reserved.
京ICP备2023020795号-1
ghs 京公网安备 11010802042870号
Book学术文献互助
Book学术文献互助群
群 号:481959085
Book学术官方微信