Reconciling Variability in Multiple Stressor Effects Using Environmental Performance Curves

Understanding the effects of multiple stressors has become a major focus in ecology and evolution. While many studies have investigated the combined effects of stressors, revealing massive variability, a mechanistic understanding that reconciles the diversity of multiple stressor outcomes is lacking. Here, we show how performance curves can fill this gap by revealing mechanisms that shape multiple stressor outcomes. Our experiments with 12 bacterial taxa, demonstrate that additional stressors alter the shape of temperature, pH and salinity performance curves. This leads to changes in stressor interaction outcomes—for example, shifts between additive, antagonistic or synergistic interactions—along gradients, revealing that small changes in a stressor along nonlinear performance curves can dramatically impact the stressor interaction. These findings help to explain the lack of generality found across multiple stressor studies and highlight how a performance curve approach can provide a more holistic view of multiple stressor interactions.