A Propensity Score-Based Comparison regarding Renal, Functional, and Surgical Outcome of Continent Cutaneous Urinary Diversions in Patients with Benign Chronic Bladder Diseases and Patients with Bladder Cancer.

Introduction: Continent cutaneous urinary diversion post-cystectomy is an established approach addressing both oncological and functional indications. However, there is a noticeable gap of evidence when it comes to comparing outcomes between these indications, especially concerning the technique of Mainz pouch I (MPI). This study aimed to close the gap by analyzing the long-term functional and renal outcomes of patients with MPI after cystectomy due to both benign and malign bladder pathologies.

Methods: In this retrospective study, we examined 173 patients, who underwent MPI surgery between 2000 and 2022. Patients were categorized into a study group (benign conditions, n = 26) and a control group (bladder cancer, n = 52) using propensity score matching. Clinical demographics, surgical outcomes, and functional/renal parameters were analyzed using unpaired t tests and χ2 tests.

Results: Patients undergoing cystectomy with MPI due to benign bladder pathologies were significantly younger and had a lower comorbidity burden compared to those with bladder cancer. In contrast to a significantly higher incidence of chemotherapy in the oncological cohort, the long-term renal function was comparable between both populations. Surgical outcomes, revisions, and postoperative complications did not differ significantly between both groups. Nearly 90% of patients in both groups showed full continence.

Conclusion: This study demonstrates the efficacy and safety of MPI surgery in both benign and malignant conditions, proving favorable long-term renal and functional outcomes.