Ambient light intensity affecting ultrasound operator detection of liver lesions in cine-clips

Introduction

Ambient light (AL) is an important factor to improve ultrasound pathology detection. However, there are no established room AL levels recommended during an ultrasound examination. We aim to examine the diagnostic accuracy using different intensity of AL for the detection of liver lesions in anonymised pre-recorded cine-clips.

Methods

Eight ultrasound operators with 5–14 years' professional experiences were prospectively recruited to evaluate 51 randomised cine-clips directly from one ultrasound machine. These 15-s clips of the right lobe of the liver in longitudinal and transverse planes were meant to simulate the ultrasound examination. Operators reviewed all cine-clips and responded to two questions per cine-clip regarding their detection performance under 3 AL settings; 3, 15 and 25 lux, at one lighting per visit. A repeat visit under each AL was performed to assess for intra-operator variability. Each operator completed six visits in total, with at least a 2-day washout period. The operators’ performance was compared against imaging reference standards from contrast CT/MRI for cine-clips with lesion and serial US for those without.

Results

AL with highest degree of diagnostic accuracy was found to be at 25 lux. Results from 8 operators revealed sensitivity ranged from 79% to 100%, specificity ranged from 94% to 100%. Positive and negative predictive values were up to 100% with AL at 25 lux. Both intra-and interrater reliability were excellent at 0.85–1.0 (0.79–0.98) and 0.98 (0.97, 0.99) respectively, with AL at 25 lux.

Conclusion

This study proved that ambient light intensity affects the ultrasound operator detection of liver lesions on cine-clips.

Implications for practice

Identifying suitable AL levels will influence future ultrasound room construct.