Seismic evaluation of non-seismically detailed RC buildings in Pakistan: performance and damage accumulation under repeated earthquakes

In the general practice of performance-based seismic assessment and dynamic analysis of building structures, the recorded ground motions from past earthquake events are selected and modified according to the site conditions and hazard level of the project’s site. For this purpose, only the mainshock earthquake event is considered for the analysis while neglecting the foreshocks and aftershocks. However, in several real cases, especially for existing RC buildings with non-seismic detailing, low- to moderate-magnitude foreshocks and aftershocks may also affect the seismic performance. Several studies have shown that the application of repeated earthquake events may lead to damage accumulation and significant seismic losses, even if the structure is at a life safety performance level. This study examines the seismic performance of mid-rise RC frame structures in Pakistan under repeated earthquakes. For this purpose, a representative case study building has been selected for the detailed analysis after surveying typical existing RC buildings in Pakistan. The detailed nonlinear finite element model is constructed and subjected to several cases of repeated earthquakes with different intensity levels. The seismic performance in terms of key demand parameters is evaluated for single earthquake scenarios (mainshock only) and seismic sequences (foreshock, mainshock, and aftershock). The results showed the application of seismic sequences has a negligible effect on the peak seismic force and displacement demands of the buildings compared to the single mainshock event. However, an increase in seismic performance indicators, including residual displacements and inelastic hysteretic energy, is observed. Resultantly, an increase in structural damage (quantified in terms of material cracking, yielding, crushing, etc.) is also observed for ground motion sequences compared to the single ground motion.