Influence of the modal damping ratio calculation method in the analysis of dynamic events obtained in structural health monitoring of bridges

Abstract

This paper includes a review of the several calculation methods available to calculate the modal damping ratio from dynamic events obtained in structural health monitoring of bridges. A comparative analysis among methods involving the logarithmic decrement, bandwidth applied over the spectrum, adjustment to the theoretical curve and random decrement technique is included. Additionally, an alternative calculation method based on signal spectra reduction has been formulated, whose main advantage lies in the fact that it directly allows the study of multiple-degrees-of-freedom systems, which describe typical structures, without the need for applying filters; this method gives extremely precise values despite simplification of the calculations. First, a comparative analysis is carried out on a set of theoretically simulated waves. In these cases, although there are differences in detail, the obtained results are reasonably close to the theoretical values. Second, an analysis of the registered accelerograms during a test campaign of a real structure, the viaduct “The Arches of Alconétar”, is performed. It has been observed that in this case, unlike what happens with the theoretical simulations, the obtained results significantly vary depending on the selected calculation method. For this reason, it is important to know which method has been used to calculate the modal damping ratio in structural health monitoring systems, as well as to be cautious in setting thresholds.