How Physical Information Underlies Causation and the Emergence of Systems at all Biological Levels

Abstract

To bring clarity, the term ‘information’ is resolved into three distinct meanings: physical pattern, statistical relations and knowledge about things. In parallel, three kinds of ’causation’ are resolved: the action of physical force constrained by physical pattern (efficient cause), cybernetic (formal cause) and statistical inference. Cybernetic causation is an expression of fundamental (necessary) logical relations, statistical inference is phenomenological, but physical information and causation are proposed as what actually happens in the physical world. Examples of the latter are given to illustrate the underlying material dynamics in a range of biological systems from the appearance of ‘synergistic information’ among multiple variables (mainly in neuroscience); positional information in multicellular development; and the organisational structure of ecological communities, especially incorporating niche construction theory. A rigorous treatment of multi-level causation is provided as well as an explanation of the causal power of non-physical information structure, especially of interaction networks. The focus on physical information as particular pattern, echoing the insights of Howard Pattee, provides a more physically grounded view of emergence, downward causation and the concept of ‘closure to efficient causation’, all now prevalent in the organisational approach to biology.