{"title":"Integrated Analysis of Seismic Sources and Structures: Understanding Earthquake Clustering During Hydraulic Fracturing","authors":"Fangxue Zhang, Yunfeng Chen, Ruijia Wang, Hongyu Yu, Hanlin Chen, Fushen Liu, Xuhua Shi","doi":"10.1029/2024jb030008","DOIUrl":null,"url":null,"abstract":"The distribution of hydraulic-fracturing-related seismicity is largely controlled by subsurface structures, yet the physical process that governs the redistribution of injected fluids and stress heterogeneity remains underexplored due to a lack of observational constraints. In this study, we monitored an active hydraulic fracturing (HF) well for two months with a surface nodal array of 60 three-component stations. We built a high-resolution catalog comprised of 1369 events (<span data-altimg=\"/cms/asset/7f67a839-ce44-465a-8177-a1e6f8b55766/jgrb57088-math-0001.png\"></span><mjx-container ctxtmenu_counter=\"3\" ctxtmenu_oldtabindex=\"1\" jax=\"CHTML\" role=\"application\" sre-explorer- style=\"font-size: 103%; position: relative;\" tabindex=\"0\"><mjx-math aria-hidden=\"true\" location=\"graphic/jgrb57088-math-0001.png\"><mjx-semantics><mjx-mrow data-semantic-children=\"6,3,5\" data-semantic-content=\"2,4\" data-semantic- data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-speech=\"negative 1.1 less than upper M less than 2.3\" data-semantic-type=\"relseq\"><mjx-mrow data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-children=\"1\" data-semantic-content=\"0\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"negative\" data-semantic-type=\"prefixop\"><mjx-mo data-semantic- data-semantic-operator=\"prefixop,−\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"subtraction\" data-semantic-type=\"operator\" rspace=\"1\" style=\"margin-left: 0.056em;\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mo><mjx-mn data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"normal\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"float\" data-semantic-type=\"number\"><mjx-c></mjx-c><mjx-c></mjx-c><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mn></mjx-mrow><mjx-mo data-semantic- data-semantic-operator=\"relseq,<\" data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-type=\"relation\" rspace=\"5\" space=\"5\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mo><mjx-mi data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"italic\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"latinletter\" data-semantic-type=\"identifier\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mi><mjx-mo data-semantic- data-semantic-operator=\"relseq,<\" data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-type=\"relation\" rspace=\"5\" space=\"5\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mo><mjx-mn data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"normal\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"float\" data-semantic-type=\"number\"><mjx-c></mjx-c><mjx-c></mjx-c><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mn></mjx-mrow></mjx-semantics></mjx-math><mjx-assistive-mml display=\"inline\" unselectable=\"on\"><math altimg=\"urn:x-wiley:21699313:media:jgrb57088:jgrb57088-math-0001\" display=\"inline\" location=\"graphic/jgrb57088-math-0001.png\" xmlns=\"http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML\"><semantics><mrow data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-children=\"6,3,5\" data-semantic-content=\"2,4\" data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-speech=\"negative 1.1 less than upper M less than 2.3\" data-semantic-type=\"relseq\"><mrow data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-children=\"1\" data-semantic-content=\"0\" data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"negative\" data-semantic-type=\"prefixop\"><mo data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-operator=\"prefixop,−\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"subtraction\" data-semantic-type=\"operator\">−</mo><mn data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"normal\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"float\" data-semantic-type=\"number\">1.1</mn></mrow><mo data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-operator=\"relseq,<\" data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-type=\"relation\"><</mo><mi data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"italic\" data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"latinletter\" data-semantic-type=\"identifier\">M</mi><mo data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-operator=\"relseq,<\" data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-type=\"relation\"><</mo><mn data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"normal\" data-semantic-parent=\"7\" data-semantic-role=\"float\" data-semantic-type=\"number\">2.3</mn></mrow>${-}1.1< M< 2.3$</annotation></semantics></math></mjx-assistive-mml></mjx-container>; Mc = −0.2). Their associated seismogenic structures are resolved by seismic reflection data and a 3D velocity model obtained from ambient noise imaging. Earthquakes concentrate near the transition zone between high and low-velocity structures, with the majority <span data-altimg=\"/cms/asset/91ec0088-4dd1-43f3-b2d7-9be960e41259/jgrb57088-math-0002.png\"></span><mjx-container ctxtmenu_counter=\"4\" ctxtmenu_oldtabindex=\"1\" jax=\"CHTML\" role=\"application\" sre-explorer- style=\"font-size: 103%; position: relative;\" tabindex=\"0\"><mjx-math aria-hidden=\"true\" location=\"graphic/jgrb57088-math-0002.png\"><mjx-semantics><mjx-mrow data-semantic-children=\"6\" data-semantic-content=\"0,7\" data-semantic- data-semantic-role=\"leftright\" data-semantic-speech=\"left parenthesis tilde 70 percent sign right parenthesis\" data-semantic-type=\"fenced\"><mjx-mo data-semantic- data-semantic-operator=\"fenced\" data-semantic-parent=\"8\" data-semantic-role=\"open\" data-semantic-type=\"fence\" style=\"margin-left: 0.056em; margin-right: 0.056em;\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mo><mjx-mrow data-semantic-children=\"5,3\" data-semantic-content=\"3\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"8\" data-semantic-role=\"endpunct\" data-semantic-type=\"punctuated\"><mjx-mrow data-semantic-children=\"4,2\" data-semantic-content=\"1\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"equality\" data-semantic-type=\"relseq\"><mjx-mrow data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"5\" data-semantic-role=\"unknown\" data-semantic-type=\"empty\"></mjx-mrow><mjx-mo data-semantic- data-semantic-operator=\"relseq,∼\" data-semantic-parent=\"5\" data-semantic-role=\"equality\" data-semantic-type=\"relation\" rspace=\"5\" space=\"5\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mo><mjx-mn data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"normal\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"5\" data-semantic-role=\"integer\" data-semantic-type=\"number\"><mjx-c></mjx-c><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mn></mjx-mrow><mjx-mi data-semantic- data-semantic-operator=\"punctuated\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"unknown\" data-semantic-type=\"punctuation\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mi></mjx-mrow><mjx-mo data-semantic- data-semantic-operator=\"fenced\" data-semantic-parent=\"8\" data-semantic-role=\"close\" data-semantic-type=\"fence\" style=\"margin-left: 0.056em; margin-right: 0.056em;\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mo></mjx-mrow></mjx-semantics></mjx-math><mjx-assistive-mml display=\"inline\" unselectable=\"on\"><math altimg=\"urn:x-wiley:21699313:media:jgrb57088:jgrb57088-math-0002\" display=\"inline\" location=\"graphic/jgrb57088-math-0002.png\" xmlns=\"http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML\"><semantics><mrow data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-children=\"6\" data-semantic-content=\"0,7\" data-semantic-role=\"leftright\" data-semantic-speech=\"left parenthesis tilde 70 percent sign right parenthesis\" data-semantic-type=\"fenced\"><mo data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-operator=\"fenced\" data-semantic-parent=\"8\" data-semantic-role=\"open\" data-semantic-type=\"fence\" stretchy=\"false\">(</mo><mrow data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-children=\"5,3\" data-semantic-content=\"3\" data-semantic-parent=\"8\" data-semantic-role=\"endpunct\" data-semantic-type=\"punctuated\"><mrow data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-children=\"4,2\" data-semantic-content=\"1\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"equality\" data-semantic-type=\"relseq\"><mrow data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-parent=\"5\" data-semantic-role=\"unknown\" data-semantic-type=\"empty\"></mrow><mo data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-operator=\"relseq,∼\" data-semantic-parent=\"5\" data-semantic-role=\"equality\" data-semantic-type=\"relation\">∼</mo><mn data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"normal\" data-semantic-parent=\"5\" data-semantic-role=\"integer\" data-semantic-type=\"number\">70</mn></mrow><mi data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-operator=\"punctuated\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"unknown\" data-semantic-type=\"punctuation\">%</mi></mrow><mo data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-operator=\"fenced\" data-semantic-parent=\"8\" data-semantic-role=\"close\" data-semantic-type=\"fence\" stretchy=\"false\">)</mo></mrow>$(\\sim 70\\%)$</annotation></semantics></math></mjx-assistive-mml></mjx-container> occurring on the high-velocity side, accompanied by abrupt variations in seismic attributes from reflection data. Particularly, relatively large (<span data-altimg=\"/cms/asset/b2aba106-1858-426f-92d6-63f80161b9d5/jgrb57088-math-0003.png\"></span><mjx-container ctxtmenu_counter=\"5\" ctxtmenu_oldtabindex=\"1\" jax=\"CHTML\" role=\"application\" sre-explorer- style=\"font-size: 103%; position: relative;\" tabindex=\"0\"><mjx-math aria-hidden=\"true\" location=\"graphic/jgrb57088-math-0003.png\"><mjx-semantics><mjx-mrow data-semantic-children=\"2,5\" data-semantic-content=\"4\" data-semantic- data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-speech=\"upper M Subscript upper L Baseline greater than\" data-semantic-type=\"relseq\"><mjx-msub data-semantic-children=\"0,1\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"latinletter\" data-semantic-type=\"subscript\"><mjx-mi data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"italic\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"2\" data-semantic-role=\"latinletter\" data-semantic-type=\"identifier\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mi><mjx-script style=\"vertical-align: -0.15em; margin-left: -0.081em;\"><mjx-mi data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"italic\" data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"2\" data-semantic-role=\"latinletter\" data-semantic-type=\"identifier\" size=\"s\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mi></mjx-script></mjx-msub><mjx-mspace style=\"width: 0.333em;\"></mjx-mspace><mjx-mo data-semantic- data-semantic-operator=\"relseq,>\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-type=\"relation\" rspace=\"5\" space=\"5\"><mjx-c></mjx-c></mjx-mo><mjx-mrow data-semantic- data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"unknown\" data-semantic-type=\"empty\"></mjx-mrow></mjx-mrow></mjx-semantics></mjx-math><mjx-assistive-mml display=\"inline\" unselectable=\"on\"><math altimg=\"urn:x-wiley:21699313:media:jgrb57088:jgrb57088-math-0003\" display=\"inline\" location=\"graphic/jgrb57088-math-0003.png\" xmlns=\"http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML\"><semantics><mrow data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-children=\"2,5\" data-semantic-content=\"4\" data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-speech=\"upper M Subscript upper L Baseline greater than\" data-semantic-type=\"relseq\"><msub data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-children=\"0,1\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"latinletter\" data-semantic-type=\"subscript\"><mi data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"italic\" data-semantic-parent=\"2\" data-semantic-role=\"latinletter\" data-semantic-type=\"identifier\">M</mi><mi data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-annotation=\"clearspeak:simple\" data-semantic-font=\"italic\" data-semantic-parent=\"2\" data-semantic-role=\"latinletter\" data-semantic-type=\"identifier\">L</mi></msub><mspace width=\"0.3333em\"></mspace><mo data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-operator=\"relseq,>\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"inequality\" data-semantic-type=\"relation\">></mo><mrow data-semantic-=\"\" data-semantic-parent=\"6\" data-semantic-role=\"unknown\" data-semantic-type=\"empty\"></mrow></mrow>${M}_{L}\\ > $</annotation></semantics></math></mjx-assistive-mml></mjx-container> 1.0) earthquakes terminate near the edge of the high-velocity zone. This distinct interface may represent a geological boundary or strong material property contrast that acts as a physical barrier to rupture propagation and migration of seismic sequence. Locally, two key nearby clusters exhibit distinct characteristics in spatial concentration, focal mechanisms and statistical features. We suggest that variations of structural dimension (i.e., fractures vs. faults) within a complex fault system can dominate the clustering behaviors. Overall, our integrated analysis provides new constraints on mechanical interactions among seismicity, local geological structure, and fluid migration during HF operations.","PeriodicalId":15864,"journal":{"name":"Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth","volume":"73 1","pages":""},"PeriodicalIF":3.9000,"publicationDate":"2025-01-03","publicationTypes":"Journal Article","fieldsOfStudy":null,"isOpenAccess":false,"openAccessPdf":"","citationCount":"0","resultStr":null,"platform":"Semanticscholar","paperid":null,"PeriodicalName":"Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth","FirstCategoryId":"89","ListUrlMain":"https://doi.org/10.1029/2024jb030008","RegionNum":2,"RegionCategory":"地球科学","ArticlePicture":[],"TitleCN":null,"AbstractTextCN":null,"PMCID":null,"EPubDate":"","PubModel":"","JCR":"Q1","JCRName":"GEOCHEMISTRY & GEOPHYSICS","Score":null,"Total":0}
引用次数: 0
Abstract
The distribution of hydraulic-fracturing-related seismicity is largely controlled by subsurface structures, yet the physical process that governs the redistribution of injected fluids and stress heterogeneity remains underexplored due to a lack of observational constraints. In this study, we monitored an active hydraulic fracturing (HF) well for two months with a surface nodal array of 60 three-component stations. We built a high-resolution catalog comprised of 1369 events (; Mc = −0.2). Their associated seismogenic structures are resolved by seismic reflection data and a 3D velocity model obtained from ambient noise imaging. Earthquakes concentrate near the transition zone between high and low-velocity structures, with the majority occurring on the high-velocity side, accompanied by abrupt variations in seismic attributes from reflection data. Particularly, relatively large ( 1.0) earthquakes terminate near the edge of the high-velocity zone. This distinct interface may represent a geological boundary or strong material property contrast that acts as a physical barrier to rupture propagation and migration of seismic sequence. Locally, two key nearby clusters exhibit distinct characteristics in spatial concentration, focal mechanisms and statistical features. We suggest that variations of structural dimension (i.e., fractures vs. faults) within a complex fault system can dominate the clustering behaviors. Overall, our integrated analysis provides new constraints on mechanical interactions among seismicity, local geological structure, and fluid migration during HF operations.
期刊介绍:
The Journal of Geophysical Research: Solid Earth serves as the premier publication for the breadth of solid Earth geophysics including (in alphabetical order): electromagnetic methods; exploration geophysics; geodesy and gravity; geodynamics, rheology, and plate kinematics; geomagnetism and paleomagnetism; hydrogeophysics; Instruments, techniques, and models; solid Earth interactions with the cryosphere, atmosphere, oceans, and climate; marine geology and geophysics; natural and anthropogenic hazards; near surface geophysics; petrology, geochemistry, and mineralogy; planet Earth physics and chemistry; rock mechanics and deformation; seismology; tectonophysics; and volcanology.
JGR: Solid Earth has long distinguished itself as the venue for publication of Research Articles backed solidly by data and as well as presenting theoretical and numerical developments with broad applications. Research Articles published in JGR: Solid Earth have had long-term impacts in their fields.
JGR: Solid Earth provides a venue for special issues and special themes based on conferences, workshops, and community initiatives. JGR: Solid Earth also publishes Commentaries on research and emerging trends in the field; these are commissioned by the editors, and suggestion are welcome.