Primary Squamous Cell Carcinoma of the Thyroid Has a Molecular Genetic Profile Distinct From That of Anaplastic Thyroid Carcinoma: A Whole Exome Sequencing and Gene Expression Profiling Study.

Abstract

Background: Primary squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) of the thyroid and anaplastic thyroid carcinoma (ATC) show significant clinical and histologic overlap. Their biological behaviors are so similar that the fifth WHO updates SCC as a morphologic pattern of ATC rather than a separate entity. However, molecular genomic evidence that determines them as the same histologic type is limited. We aimed to explore whether they belong to the same classification from a molecular-typing perspective.

Methods: A cohort enrolled 15 SCCs and 15 ATCs was collected. Whole exome sequencing (WES) and RNA-sequencing were performed to analyze molecular genetic and gene-expression profiles.

Results: Significantly differential-mutant genes were BRAF, DPCR1, PCYOX1L, BRSK2, NRG1, PRR14L, TET1, VAMP4 suggesting differences in mutation level, as well as differences in high-frequency mutated genes, and SCC had a much lower tumor mutation burden than ATC. Mutational co-occurrence and mutual exclusion were less frequent in SCC than in ATC. 2047 differential-express genes were screened, indicating differences in gene expression were extremely strong. In principal component analysis, ATC and SCC could be notably clustered together, respectively, meanwhile they could be explicitly distinguished. Unsupervised clustering analysis validated they can indeed be clearly separated from each other which demonstrated that they may be two distinctive entities.

Conclusions: It is controversial yet SCC is classified as a morphologic pattern of ATC. We revealed that SCC exhibited molecular genetic characteristics distinct from ATC. Although the fifth WHO categorizes them together, this study may provide strong molecular genetic evidence for the next edition of WHO classification that may allow for the separation of thyroid SCC from ATC.