[Online survey to determine realistic success rates and trends in surgical septal perforation repair].

Abstract

Objective: High success rates (SR) for surgical septal perforation repair (SPR) of over 90 % are reported in the literature. We think that realistic SR are significantly lower and wanted to confirm this thesis with the help of a survey among ear, nose, throat ENT specialists from Germany. Surgical trends were also queried.

Material and methods: An anonymous online survey among ENT specialists in Germany was conducted. 356 doctors participated. The collected SR were statistically evaluated, and the operative trends were analysed. It applies a significance level α = 0.05. The SR were collected for 3 different size categories (<1 cm, 1-2 cm, >2 cm).

Results: The SR for SPR <1 cm (median 79 %) was higher than that for 1-2 cm (60 %) and >2 cm (40 %). Surgeons estimated SR significantly higher (90 %, 75 %, 50 %; p-value <0.001 each) than non-surgeons (80 %, 50 %, 25 %). Hospital-based physicians (90 %, 70 %, 50 %) reported significantly higher SR than ambulatory physicians (80 %, 50 %, 30 %, p-value <0.001 each). No linear relationship was found between the total number of SPR performed and SR (r <1cm = 0.16, r1-2cm = 0.18, r >2cm = 0.19). Most SPR were performed with the bridge flap technique (73 %), a closed surgical approach (85 %), an interposition graft (74 %) and postoperative splinting (94 %).

Conclusions: The subjective SR suggest that the SR of SPR is lower than described in the literature. This may be due to short follow-up times, small patient populations and a retrospective design of existing studies. The variety of surgical possibilities confirms the complexity of SPR. Optimising the design of future studies could help to collect realistic SR.