Retreat from the Golden Age: Russian Journalists & Their World, 1992-2000

Abstract

ABSTRACTThe overall processes in the first decade of independent Russian media can be divided into distinct phases. The first phase was characterized by a golden age of political independence in the early 1990s. This was followed by a shift toward partial government control and increased proximity to the ruling elites by the presidential elections of 1999. The final phase saw the transfer of power to Vladimir Putin in 2000. The authors argue that several factors contributed to the loss of independence in Russian media during this period, including the complicated economic realities of a transitional society, the growing interest of new financial tycoons (oligarchs) in media ownership, and the reassertion of political influences. Additionally, the specific understanding of professionalism among most Russian journalists played a significant role in the transformation from independent to controlled journalism.KEYWORDS: Censorshipfreedom of pressjournalismpost-SovietRussia AcknowledgmentOwen V. Johnson died August 6, 2022. His lead co-author completed the article, and it is being published posthumously with his family’s permission. For several years, Dr. Johnson was a reviewer/contributing editor of Journalism History. He is greatly missed by the division and this journal.Disclosure StatementNo potential conflict of interest was reported by the author(s).Notes1. Alexander Filippov, “Sociologia Professii,” in Rossijskaja Sociologicheskaja Jenciklopedija (Moscow: Norma-Infra, 1998), http://sociology.niv.ru/doc/encyclopedia/sociology/fc/slovar-209–3.htm#zag-1115.2. Michael Quinn Patton, Qualitative Research and Evaluation Methods: Integrating Theory and Practice (Los Angeles: SAGE, 2014), 103–106.3. Konstantin Vetrov, Sredstva Massovoj Informacii Postsovetskoj Rossii: Osobyj Put’ Vdol’ Protorennoj Dorogi (Moscow: Kniga i Biznes, 2004), 96.4. Ian Zasurskij, “Pressa v Uslovijah Rynka: Uchrediteli i Sponsory,” Vestnik Moskovskogo Universiteta, Zhurnalistika 10, no. 6 (1992).5. RIA Novosti, “Otmena 6-j Stat’i Konstitucii SSSR o Rukovodjashhej Roli KPSS. Spravka,” March 14, 2010, https://ria.ru/20100314/213855855.html.6. Anastasia Bespalova, Evgeni Kornilov, and Anatoli Korochenski, “Tendencii Razvitija Zhurnalistiki Perioda Perestrojki i Poslednego Desjatiletija XX Veka,” in Istorija Mirovoj Zhurnalistiki (Moscow: Izdatel’stvo MarT, 2003), https://science.lecture.center/istoriya-jurnalistiki_852/tendentsii-razvitiya-jurnalistiki-perioda.html.7. Ivan Kuznecov, “Zhurnalistika Rossijskoj Federacii,” in Istorija Otechestvennoj Zhurnalistiki (1917–2000) (Moscow: Flinta: Nauka, 2002), http://evartist.narod.ru/text8/17.htm.8. Vsesoiuznaia Knijnaia Palata, Statisticheskij Sbornik, Pechat’ Rossijskoj Federacii v 1991 godu (Moscow: Finansy i statistika, 1992).9. Vetrov, Sredstva Massovoj Informacii Postsovetskoj Rossii, 126.10. Natalia Roudakova, Losing Pravda: Ethics and the Press in Post-Truth Russia (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2017), 101.11. Pravo SSSR, “Ukaz Prezidenta SSSR o Demokratizacii i Razvitii Televidenija i Radioveshhanija v SSSR,” Ukaz no. 357, adopted July 14, 1990, http://pravo.levonevsky.org/baza/soviet/sssr0813.htm.12. Ian Zasurskij, “Media-Politicheskaya Sistema,” in Mass-Media Vtoroj Respubliki (Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo Universiteta, 1999), http://evartist.narod.ru/text3/40.htm.13. Eurozine, “‘Don’t Let the Facts Spoil a Good Story,’” June 16, 2017, https://www.eurozine.com/dont-let-the-facts-spoil-a-good-story/.14. Ian Zasurskij, “Mediatizatsia politiki,” in Mass-Media Vtoroj Respubliki (Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo Universiteta, 1999), http://evartist.narod.ru/text3/39.htm.15. Luisa Svitich, Fenomen Zhurnalizma (Moscow: Izdatel’stvo IKAR, 2000), 117.16. Kuznecov, “Zhurnalistika Rossijskoj Federacii.”17. Ian Zasurskij, “Slovo I delo,” in Mass-Media Vtoroj Respubliki (Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo Universiteta, 1999), http://evartist.narod.ru/text3/38.htm.18. Svitich, Fenomen Zhurnalizma.19. Bespalova et al., Tendencii Razvitija Zhurnalistiki.20. Ian Zasurskij, “Zhurnalistika v Izmenjajuzemsja Mire,” in Iskushenie Svobodoj. Rossijskaja Zhurnalistika: 1990–2007 (Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo Universiteta, 2004), 181–84.21. Rafail Ovsepjan, “Rossiyskaya Zhurnalistika v Protivorechivom Protsesse Perekhodnogo Perioda,” in V Labirintah Istorii Otechestvennoj Zhurnalistiki: Vek XX (Moscow: RIP-Holding, 2001), 258–311.22. Vladimir Kulev, Delovaja Pressa Rossii: Sostojaniie i Perspektivy (Moscow: Vysshaja Shkola, 1996), 5.23. Rafail Ovsepjan, “Zhurnalistika Rossiyskoy Federatsii (90-e gg.),” in Istorija Novejshej Otechestvennoj Zhurnalistiki (Fevral’ 1917-Nachalo 90-h Godov): Uchebnoe Posobie (Moscow: Izdatel’stvo Moskovskogo Universiteta, 2004), https://www.gumer.info/bibliotek_Buks/Gurn/Ovsep/_08_a.php.24. Kuznecov, “Zhurnalistika Rossijskoj Federacii.”25. Kuznecov.26. Vetrov, Sredstva Massovoj Informacii Postsovetskoj Rossii, 46.27. Vetrov, 231.28. Ovsepjan, Rossiyskaya Zhurnalistika v Protivorechivom Protsesse Perekhodnogo Perioda.29. Zasurskij, Pressa v Uslovijah Rynka.30. Vetrov, Sredstva Massovoj Informacii Postsovetskoj Rossii, 96.31. Zasurskij, Pressa v Uslovijah Rynka.32. Zasurskij.33. Zasurskij, Mediatizatsia politiki.34. Ovsepjan, Rossiyskaya Zhurnalistika v Protivorechivom Protsesse Perekhodnogo Perioda.35. Kuznecov, Zhurnalistika Rossijskoj Federacii.36. Zasurskij, Pressa v Uslovijah Rynka.37. Zasurskij.38. Ian Zasurskij, “Zhurnalistika i Vlast,” Vestnik Moskovskogo Universiteta, Zhurnalistika 10, no. 3 (2005).39. Viktor Muchnik, “Mestnye Novosti: Centr Rossii,” Sreda, June 6, 2001.40. Zasurskij, Mediatizatsia politiki.41. The Chechen wars played a significant role in the public’s perception of the new Russian journalism. While this played a role in the declining independence of journalists, the question is too complex to include in this article. The media’s reaction to the war in Chechnya was mostly homogenous—they were against the war and demanded that president Yeltsin find a peaceful solution of the problem. These sentiments intensified in the mid-1990s, close to the end of First Chechen War. Even competing media outlets from different sides of political spectrum largely agreed on the problematics of military actions (Piter Hlebnikov, Zhurnalistika i Vojna: Osveshhenie Rossijskimi SMI Voennyh Dejstvij v Chechne (Moscow: Rossijsko-amerikanskij Informacionnyj Press-centr, 1995), 11.42. Vetrov, Sredstva Massovoj Informacii Postsovetskoj Rossii, 140.43. Josef Dzjaloshinskij, “Zhurnalist v mire ideologiy,” in Rossijskij Zhurnalist v Posttotalitarnuju Epohu (Moscow: Vostok, 1996), http://www.dzyalosh.ru/03–05-Russ-Jornal-Boock.html.44. Svitich, Fenomen Zhurnalizma, 38.45. Priamaia Rech, “Oktjabr’ 1993 v Licah,” Kommersant, March 10, 2013, https://www.kommersant.ru/doc/2309753.46. Wei Wu, David Weaver, and Owen V. Johnson, “Professional Roles of Russian and U.S. Journalists: A Comparative Study,” Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 73, no. 3 (September 1996), https://doi.org/10.1177/107769909607300303.47. Vetrov, Sredstva Massovoj Informacii Postsovetskoj Rossii, 162; Zasurskij, Pressa v Uslovijah Rynka; Bespalova et al., Tendencii Razvitija Zhurnalistiki; and Ovsepjan, Rossiyskaya Zhurnalistika v Protivorechivom Protsesse Perekhodnogo Perioda.48. Thomas F. Remington, The Truth of Authority: Ideology and Communication in the Soviet Union (Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1988), 169.49. Jane Leftwich Curry, Poland’s Journalists: Professionalism and Politics (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2009).50. Rilla Dean Mills, “The Soviet Journalist: A Cultural Analysis” (PhD dissertation, University of Illinois, 1981), 218.51. Elena Prokhorov, Zhurnalistika i Demokratia, 2nd ed. (Moscow: Aspekt Press, 2004), 45.52. Luiza G. Svitich and Alla A. Shiryaeva, “Changes in Russian Journalism,” in World of Media: Yearbook of Russian Media & Journalism Studies, ed. Elena L. Vartanova (2009), 166–89.53. Thomas F. Remington, “Politics and Professionalism in Soviet Journalism,” in The Truth of Authority: Ideology and Communication in the Soviet Union (Pittsburgh, PA: University of Pittsburgh Press, 1988), 157–180.54. Wu et al., “Professional Roles of Russian and U.S. Journalists”; Ian Zasurskij and Svetlana Kolesnik, “Zhurnalisty o Pravakh i Svobodakh Lichnosti i Sredstv Massovoy Informatsii (Rossiysko-Amerikanskoe Issledovanie),” Vestnik Moskovskogo Universiteta 10, no. 5 (1997).55. Wu et al., “Professional Roles of Russian and U.S. Journalists”; and Zasurskij et al., “Zhurnalisty o Pravakh i Svobodakh Lichnosti i Sredstv Massovoy Informatsii.”56. Wu et al., “Professional Roles of Russian and U.S. Journalists.”57. Wu et al.58. Wu et al.59. Leonid Bershidsky, “Media Code Aims to Stem Corruption,” Moscow Times, June 26, 1994.60. Elisabeth Schimpfössl and Ilya Yablokov, “Power Lost and Freedom Relinquished: Russian Journalists Assessing the First Post-Soviet Decade,” Russian Review 76, no. 3 (2017).61. Aleksei Simonov, Zhurnalist i Zhurnalistika v Rossijskij Provincii (Sent’jabr’-Dekabr’ 1994) (Moscow: Nachalo Press, 1995), 4.62. Wu et al., “Professional Roles of Russian and U.S. Journalists.”63. Wu et al.64. Svetlana Juskevits. “Professional Roles of Russian Journalists at the End of the 1990s: A Case Study of St. Petersburg Media” (PhD dissertation, Tampere University, 2002), 186.65. Svetlana Pasti, “Concepts of Professional Journalism: Russia after the Collapse of Communism,” in Medien und Demokratie/Media & Democracy: Europäische Erfahrungen/Experiences from Europe, ed. Frank Marcinkowski (Bern: Haupt Verlag, 2006), 73–89.Additional informationNotes on contributorsRashad MammadovRashad Mammadov, PhD, is an associate professor at University of the Fraser Valley in Canada. His research interests focus on the history of government-media relationships, the implementation of mass communication theories to the media systems of countries with developing democracies, and media realities under different political systems. His track record of combined experience in higher education institutions around the world includes teaching both skill classes and courses covering global media and political communication.Owen V. JohnsonOwen V. Johnson, PhD, was associate professor emeritus at Indiana University, Bloomington. His research was focused on several areas, including Slovak mass media and nation in the twentieth century; the letters and columns of World War II correspondent Ernie Pyle; and the history of Russian journalists. His interests extended more generally to mass media in East Central and Eastern Europe, particularly from the historical perspective.